Hudson Valley Resort

2/10

Poor

20 Oct 2025

Joanne

hotel booked though Expedia. we had 4 adults with 2 rooms. we were not informed thay the hotel was closed and the property was vacant. we were stranded , had to cancel our plans and drive back 200 miles. Expedia is not fairly compensating for ruining our plans snd causing a major inconvenience. am recieveing the worst customer service .

Leisure Friends

2/10

Poor

14 Oct 2025

Christine

Not a resort or spa. It’s used for private retreats for the Jewish community. We came for the pool per the pictures but the pool has booked, segregated male and female swim times so we couldn’t use it. Everything is worn down and dirty - it’s basically like an abandoned hotel like the Shining. Empty food wrappers and bottles, and broken furniture were everywhere. The paint is peeling and tile falling off in many places. To top it off, the electricity stopped and water pressure significantly decreased so we had to walk up and down 6 flights w a toddler to leave. On the bright side, the staff are nice and try their best w what they have. They also had bouncers outside from an event and indoor toddler playroom and basement playroom for bigger kids w an arcade and ping pong table. But the sanitary / safety levels were questionable. I don’t know how this passes code and inspection for a “hotel”. Please look at guest photos. The 5 hotel pics are deceiving.

Leisure Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

13 Oct 2025

Jose

Pro

Decent price. Beautiful views. Quite. Staff was very nice. Great water pressure.


Cons

It is what you expect for 3 stars. It’s like a motel room with a view. The outside of the property is in disrepair. The inside of the property is antiquated and needs updating. No food on site. Could not find a vending machine. This hotel is geared for Jewish families. Only 2 channels work on the TV.

Leisure Family_with_children

2/10

Poor

12 Oct 2025

Timothy

The pictures haven’t been updated in decades. This hotel is the place where nightmares come to get scared.

Leisure Partner

4/10

Poor

30 Sep 2025

Claire

haunted, smelled of urine, and dusty but very fun to explore. Should have come here 40 years ago. Seriously this place is disgusting however we had a very fun time exploring what seemed to be an almost abandoned hotel. So we would come back but not for sleeping.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

28 Sep 2025

Timothy

The staff, specifically henry, made my stay wonderful.

Business_and_leisure

10/10

Exceptional

17 Nov 2024

Darren

The stay was fine. It’s an tired old hotel in a rural area…but was clean and cheap. I’m good with that.

Leisure Family

4/10

Poor

08 Nov 2024

terry

The room was not clean broken drawer and lamp shades. no shower, water was brown. Room was dirty.

Leisure Self

4/10

Poor

03 Nov 2024

Stephanie

The water was brown when first turned on. It had a weird smell and you can tell that nothing has been wiped down, the remote was sticky

Leisure Friends

2/10

Poor

27 Oct 2024

Neil

This place should be condemned . You can tell.that back in the day it was a beautiful place. Do not stay here.

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

18 Oct 2024

Marshall

It was not as grimey or disgusting as I expected it to be. Bed was very comfy. Great location right between the Shawangunks and thr Catskills. Does look abandoned on the outside. Probably the oddest hotel I have been to. This place has a lot of potential, just needs some sprucing up.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

14 Oct 2024

Hardik

It’s very easy to communicate nice big property working staff excellent

Leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

13 Oct 2024

Yuliya

Great place

10/10

Exceptional

13 Oct 2024

mary

We will come back

The price was great and the staff were super friendly!

Friends_and_family Family

6/10

Pleasant

13 Oct 2024

Verified traveler

OK to sleep, but overpriced

Not worth the price, in my opinion. This was my first stay here, so I can’t speak to any changes or improvements. The hotel is old and the rooms are in OK-to-poor shape. It’s evident that some renovations have been done, but they don’t really eliminate the “way past its prime” vibe of the hotel.

Self

10/10

Exceptional

12 Oct 2024

Tom

Henry at the front desk was very friendly and helpful and apologized for nothing as all is normal to the staff. But yes, everything is tired looking in terms of decorating and very outdated but it is all passable and when leaves are turning, nothing wrong at half the price and the only place below $400 that has rooms available.

Their problem is it's virtue. Prospective guests need to rearrange their expectations. Yes, the whole place is an odd combination of huge impressive first floor common areas, and a big outdoor pool which is drained and an eyesore. (although the indoor pool in the basement is open 24/7). The reviews were so poor, I was expecting to walk in and tiptoe over the debris. But it is such an oddity, an 8 story behemoth in the middle of nowhere, you will be taking pictures and laughing with your family and friends at the next visit. You can tell them there is one elevator button for the left car for those on odd floors and the same button that goes to the even floors on the right car. It is a white elephant, a non-sequitur, an anachronism where they think it is perfectly normal to make a broken down hotel into what they may think is an over the top AirBnB. Go in with the right attitude and It should be on everyone's list who wants a cheap life-long memory that will bring a smile to your face even when you are happily leaving.

Leisure Self

2/10

Poor

09 Oct 2024

MICHAEL

Disgusting place, should be closed down. My room wasn't vacuumed before I came, no one came to clean to while I was there either. The shower barely worked, the elevators barely work, the stairwells are gross, room was gross, pool area is closed and trashed, it smells gross in the lobby, the lobby furniture is disgusting, absolutely nothing redeemable about this place. It was probably nice once is all I can say. I am going to contact my card company, because it was pretty unacceptable conditions and the fact that they are charging nearly $200 a night is INSANE and a scam. Should be condemned.

Self

4/10

Poor

06 Oct 2024

Sigrid

Horrible hotel

We went to this hotel because it was close to the college where we were visiting our daughter. It was really outdated, smelled old and was really visibly dirty.
We won’t be back. This hotel and spa should be torn down. Weeds growing in The parking lot, the building has exposed paint cracked and chips, broken entrance to the hotel.

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

06 Oct 2024

Cathrine

I did not even stay in the hotel, we pulled in and it was absolutely disgusting. The front doors would not even open! It was filthy. Disgusting we had to find another place to stay and they would not refund my money! I am so disappointed! Will never ever ever use hotels.com again

4/10

Poor

06 Oct 2024

Jaime

The property is old and antiquated - not in a cool vintage way - and it’s long due for an update.
The room was unkept - maintenance and cleanliness wise.
Lamps not working, lamp shades worn out/broken, damaged closet door poorly fixed, and a grimy sticky spot by the coffee machine - clearly not cleaned in a long time.

Do not recommend.

Leisure Partner

8/10

Excellent

29 Sep 2024

Juan

Reading some reviews, we were hesitant to book. Property is large and old. Lobby is huge. We checked in 10:30pm and was greeted by very friendly and helpful staff. There was a party going on in banquet hall, so it was quiet lively, festive. Lobby is huge, with big chandeliers. Room was clean, rug was older but clean. Desk was wobbly but we did not need to use it. We only stayed one night, but it met our need. We attended Meadowlark festival in Stone Ridge, Easy to find at night.
Had clean comfortable bed and working shower. .Keurig in room, but did not see coffee or cups. Had refrigerator. No restaurant on site, not a problem , went to Saunderkill Farm for breakfast on Route 209. I would stay here again.

Leisure Family

2/10

Poor

22 Sep 2024

Eva

This hotel is absolutely disgusting I checked in and left in a matter of 1 hour because it looked like a crime scene when I walked in to my room. There is also a door that is connected to another room and that is sus af. I’ve seen enough movies to know I don’t wanna be killed. Never ever coming back here. Also smells like cat piss.

Business_and_leisure Self

4/10

Poor

04 Sep 2024

Victor

Didn’t have in a room what was promised

Leisure Family

2/10

Poor

01 Sep 2024

Nancy

We should receive a refund. This hotel couldn’t possibly pass an inspection and I wonder about the safety of the elevators as well. The description of the Hudson Valley Resort and Spa is extremely deceptive. It was absolutely run down and filthy. Towels were all over the hallway when we arrived and were there when we checked out. Ceiling tiles were falling. The lobby had food on the floor from children and a turned over stroller that seemed to be ok sitting there. The garbage bin outside the building was overflowing with crap. I took pictures if you would like them. The rugs are all stained. Where is the building inspector? The check in staff were all very nice- that’s about it. Requesting a full refund! I have several pics of the filth. We’re disgusted to say the least.

2/10

Poor

04 Aug 2024

Beth

Lobby and outskirts of hotel were filthy. Indoor pool was disgusting. The hotel hasn’t been kept up and it’s falling apart. Hairdryer in room didn’t work and we were going to a wedding so hairstyle was important. Outdoor pool in disrepair. Elevator maintenance questionable.

Leisure Partner

2/10

Poor

02 Aug 2024

Shannon

Hudson Valley Stay

This was a strange experience. My key didn’t work and the elevators are very very old. There were dirty plates, cups, dishes with old food and coffee everywhere in the hallways. Dirty towels strewn about. There was hair in the bathtub and only shampoo and two lotions provided. The air conditioner was not on and unable to be adjusted. She floors were dirty and the whole place had a strange odor. I would never stay here again.

Self

2/10

Poor

02 Aug 2024

Evan

This place needs to be condemned immediately. It's structure is falling apart. It's delapitated. The furniture is old. The decorations are worn and extremely dated. All charm is lost on the wear and tear of everything. Smelled like mold and water damage when you enter. This place needs to be shut down. I did not see cockroaches but it wouldn't surprise me if there were heavy pest problems as well, though this is just speculation. My assumption is always, how somebody does one thing, is how they do everything! And if this place is to judge, everything is a problem. The window in our room, was barely held together with ad hoc wood trimmings. This place needs to be sold and leveled.

Leisure Family_with_children

8/10

Excellent

28 Jul 2024

helene

We found it unique and close to most of the activities we were interested in. The breakfast was nice and the seating outside was very accommodating with a nice view. We did use the hiking trail in the property and our dog enjoyed the trail as well. The room we had was next to the entrance so it was slightly noisy, but we had the air on in the evening so it wasn’t an issue. The not so great part was the check in because the person that checked us in was extremely rude. We also had no Netflix and after calling the same person at reception , we were told the property was in some type of transition and Netflix and other TV capabilities were not available. My daughter was also told that SOME people fin it hard to operate a remote control. We were also told at. Our 5 pm checkin our 9 lb dog was an additional 75.00 (
And if we didn’t like it , we could leave) . being a service dog we were surprised and did not see mention of that on the property website other than the hotel was dog friendly. We did basically enjoy the one night stay , the owner was hospitable and made up for the nasty woman that checked us in . The person on evening shift at the desk was nice as well. It’s hard getting past the initial condescending attitude especially since the check in process sets the tone first thing however we wouldn’t allow an obviously troubled person to ruin our stay. Enjoy the natural beauty.

Leisure Family

6/10

Pleasant

19 Jul 2024

Verified traveler

Tired and run down

Hotel is tired and obviously has not been renovated in decades. Staff is very friendly and tries to be helpful, given the limitations with which they have to work.

Friends_and_family Family

6/10

Pleasant

19 Jul 2024

JUAN

THE GUY WORKIN THE FRONT DESK WAS ONLY THING THAT WAS POSITIVE

10/10

Exceptional

27 May 2024

Oleksandr

We stayed one night, clean room, clean bathroom, we saw a live bear in the parking lot.

Leisure Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

27 May 2024

Hector

Thank is very god is to old but is god

10/10

Exceptional

26 May 2024

Darlene

Easy check in, beautiful entrance, comfortable beds!

2/10

Poor

02 Jan 2024

Andrew

There is absolutely NO WAY anyone should stay at this property. I have photos. Please advise how to share them with you.

Leisure Family

4/10

Poor

04 Dec 2023

Kayla

The staff were great and the the room itself was clean and had everything we needed. There was no spa. The indoor pool was very outdated and not very clean or warm especially since it’s December. The elevators are very old and seems to not have been updated since they first built the building. The property had a lot of potential but it is very outdated and needs lots of repairs. While checking out it was pouring outside and there was a huge leak in the lobby. Our overall stay was good but we wish it was more of a spa like stay like we thought.

4/10

Poor

05 Nov 2023

Jorge

The other poor views weren kidding. This once was a premier mountain resort that fell into pathetic and shocking disrepair. Most areas are shuttered. The carpeting is filthy throughout but thankfully the beds were clean. Sad place. Stay at a B&B instead.

Leisure

8/10

Excellent

23 Oct 2023

Debra

The room was large and clean and the beds were very comfortable

Leisure Family

6/10

Pleasant

22 Oct 2023

Verified traveler

Disappointing

This place was probably very nice at one time but is very run down now. The elevators hardly worked and I didn’t sleep the entire first night I was there because I could physically hear the elevators running all night. My room was big but there were stains all over the carpet and the furniture. I leaned on the desk in my room and it almost fell apart because it was so wobbly. Kids and families constantly just hanging out and sitting in the lobby even at late hours in the night.

This is more like a motel than a “resort and spa”. Great surrounding views but not worth it in my opinion.

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

20 Oct 2023

Falk

Unhealthy dump

I can’t believe the health department hasn’t shut this place down. Mold in the bathroom. The weight room ceiling has a hole in it. The debris is all over the floor and the weight machines and the ceiling is covered in black mold. The ceiling over the pool has paint peeling and falling into the pool. Stains on the carpet everywhere. Bed was like sleeping on a piece of plywood.

Self

2/10

Poor

15 Oct 2023

Stacy

Do NOT stay here

This place is awful, I have no idea how it’s in business the rooms need updating there were tears in the walls, by the pool the ceiling is falling and a huge hole in the ceiling by the gym equipment. There is no way this place is up to code it should be shut Down

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

08 Oct 2023

Deanna

our first room we were placed in did not have working air conditioning, a working phone and a lock on the door was broke so we got moved to another room where again the door did not lock, and the phone did not work. The whole property is really rundown, the lobby bathroom had missing ceiling tiles the whole place smelled terrible. The pool area was disgusting. Our room was clean, but had bad stained carpet peeling wallpaper. The whole property needs a facelift. On the plus side the staff was very friendly.

Leisure Partner

4/10

Poor

08 Oct 2023

Jerry

This old hotel is out in the middle of nowhere. 30 minutes on very curvy roads. Facilities are old and not maintained. Can't get the smell out of my head.

Leisure Self

6/10

Pleasant

11 Sep 2023

Stewart

The lobby is clean and nice. The staff is friendly and accommodating. The outdoors area is is an extremely poor condition, weeds growing though sidewalks, grounds have zero maintenance. The rooms are old and worn with holes in the walls from pictures and other items removed. The door to my room did not have a secondary lock; the chain lock was broken and the dead bolt did not work. The room was clean and the bed comfortable. The rest of the hotel outside of the room and lobby is falling apart and should be bulldozed.

Friends_and_family Friends

2/10

Poor

03 Sep 2023

Douglas

There was literally poop on the floor by the elevator.

Family

4/10

Poor

26 Jul 2023

Gina

Do. Not. Stay. Here. The pictures are nothing like the actual property. Manager was very nice and accommodating, however, property was unkept and unsanitary. There seems to be a Jewish camp that attends here and/or lives at this property. Kids are running around everywhere and on every floor.

6/10

Pleasant

05 Jun 2023

diane

Old property. Creepy and wonderful. A glimpse of the past. Hopefully on its way to
Recovery

Leisure Self

6/10

Pleasant

24 Oct 2022

Peter

Descent place to stay at a reasonable price. A little old, needs updating.

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

24 Oct 2022

David

The view was amazing from my room.

Leisure Partner

8/10

Excellent

24 Oct 2022

Shara

This was modest place to stay. My room was large and clean. It looked out on the most beautiful tree filled with golden yellow and orange leaves. The space has seen better days, but the price was right and they allowed pets.

Leisure Pet

4/10

Poor

24 Oct 2022

Hong

The representative was so nice when we check in, but the room make me so disappoint. I killed two big flying bugs in the room!! And the facilities within the room are super old. Shower either too hot or too cold. Window so dirty! Just one night is enough. Never book here again.

Leisure Family_with_children