Show prices in

Choose a currency for your trip.

More currencies

More crypto

Find your next stay

Bonefish Bay Motel

Florida Keys - FL · United States

12565 Overseas HighwayView location

9.2/10Excellent665 Reviews
Cleanliness9.6/109.6
Service9.4/109.4
Comfort8.8/108.8
Condition9.2/109.2
Amenities9.2/109.2
See all ratings
Check availability Pay with crypto or card

Room prices, availability, meal plans and cancellation terms are confirmed for your selected dates.

About Bonefish Bay Motel

Offering free WiFi throughout the property, a sun terrace with a swimming pool and a garden, Bonefish Bay Motel is located in Marathon. The property is around 1. 5 miles from Sunset Park Beach, 28 miles from Upper Matecumbe Key and 10 miles from Seven Mile Bridge.

Guests can enjoy garden views. Complete with a private bathroom equipped with a shower and free toiletries, the rooms at the motel have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and certain rooms come with a balcony. At Bonefish Bay Motel rooms have bed linen and towels.

Popular points of interest near the accommodation include Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters, A Deep Blue Dive Center and Captain Hook s Marina Dive Center. The nearest airport is Key West International Airport, 51 miles from Bonefish Bay Motel.

Read more about this hotelShow less

When you stay at Bonefish Bay Motel in Marathon, you'll be on the waterfront, just steps from Coco Plum Beach and 8 minutes by foot from San Pablo Catholic Church.

This motel is 0.7 mi (1.1 km) from Curry Hammock State Park and 5.5 mi (8.8 km) from The Turtle Hospital. Make yourself at home in one of the 11 individually decorated guestrooms, featuring microwaves and Smart televisions.

Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and digital programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms have shower/tub combinations and hair dryers. Conveniences include electric kettles, and housekeeping is provided daily. Featured amenities include express check-in, express check-out, and laundry facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.

Popular amenities

Free WiFi
Parking available
Dining services
Concierge
Laundry
Entertainment
Non-smoking
Accessible facilities

Check-in and check-out

Check-in from 3:00 PM
Check-in until anytime
Check-out until 11:00 AM
Minimum check-in age 21

Hotel policies

Beach nearby No rollaway/extra beds available No cribs (infant beds) available No elevators By ocean Professional property host/manager Pets allowed Only dogs are allowed Service animals are allowed Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions

Cleaning and safety

Sanitization
Contactless check-in is available Contactless check-out is available Cashless transactions are available
Essential Travel
Essential workers only - NO

Important information

  • You need to know
    • Pool access available from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
    • Cashless payment methods are available for all transactions.
    • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.
  • Special Instructions
    The front desk is open daily from 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. For any questions, please contact the property using the information on the booking confirmation. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
  • Instructions
    • Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
    • Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
    • Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
    • This property accepts credit cards, debit cards, and cash
    • This property reserves the right to pre-authorize the guest's credit card prior to arrival.
    • Cashless transactions are available
    • Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher
    • Please note that cultural norms and guest policies may differ by country and by property; the policies listed are provided by the property
    • Guests must contact this property in advance to reserve a boat slip.
  • Minimal age
    21
  • Optional fees
    • Pet fee: USD 75.00 per accommodation, per stay
    • Service animals are exempt from fees

    The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.

  • Spoken Language

    English

Nearby attractions

Coco Plum Beach 0.1 km / 0.1 mi
Marathon Visitor Center 0.6 km / 0.4 mi
San Pablo Catholic Church 0.7 km / 0.4 mi
Sunset Park Beach 0.8 km / 0.5 mi
Curry Hammock State Park 0.9 km / 0.5 mi
Captain Hooks Marina and Dive Center 1.1 km / 0.7 mi
Marathon Air Museum 2.4 km / 1.5 mi
Crawl Key 5 km / 3.1 mi
Crane Point Museum and Nature Center 6 km / 3.7 mi
Boot Key Harbor 7.1 km / 4.4 mi
Florida Keys Country Club 7.2 km / 4.5 mi
Fishermen's Community Hospital 8.2 km / 5.1 mi
Shady Palm Art Gallery 8.6 km / 5.3 mi
The Turtle Hospital 8.8 km / 5.5 mi
Sombrero Beach 9.1 km / 5.6 mi

Hotel facilities & services

Services and fees can vary. Check the selected room details and hotel policies before booking.

  • Total number of rooms: 11
  • hotel
  • Wheelchair-accessible
  • Car park
  • Check-in hour
  • Check-out hour
  • Wi-fi
  • Laundry service
  • Garden
  • Terrace
  • Grill/BBQ
  • Outdoor freshwater pool
Show 1 more facilities & services
  • Picnic
Upon availability

Room types

These are the hotel's room types, rather than live offers. Choose your travel dates to see available rooms, prices and booking conditions. Check availability

  • SUITE DELUXE KING BEDSUITE • DELUXE KING BEDSUI.DX-KG

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    SUITE DELUXE KING BED

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–8 • Adults: max. 8 • Children: max. 5
    Room type
    SUITE
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE KING BED

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: SUI.DX-KG

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • QUADRUPLE SUPERIOR QUEEN BEDQUADRUPLE • SUPERIOR QUEEN BEDQUA.QN-SU

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    QUADRUPLE SUPERIOR QUEEN BED

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
    Room type
    QUADRUPLE
    View / characteristic
    SUPERIOR QUEEN BED

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: QUA.QN-SU

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • QUADRUPLE DELUXE GARDEN VIEWQUADRUPLE • DELUXE GARDEN VIEWQUA.DX-GV

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    QUADRUPLE DELUXE GARDEN VIEW

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
    Room type
    QUADRUPLE
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE GARDEN VIEW

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: QUA.DX-GV

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • Room DELUXERoom • DELUXEROO.DX

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    Room DELUXE

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
    Room type
    Room
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: ROO.DX

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • DOUBLE DELUXE CAPACITY 2DOUBLE • DELUXE CAPACITY 2DBL.C2-DX

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    DOUBLE DELUXE CAPACITY 2

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
    Room type
    DOUBLE
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE CAPACITY 2

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: DBL.C2-DX

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • DOUBLE DELUXE KING BEDDOUBLE • DELUXE KING BEDDBL.DX-KG

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    DOUBLE DELUXE KING BED

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
    Room type
    DOUBLE
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE KING BED

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: DBL.DX-KG

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • SINGLE DELUXE GARDEN VIEWSINGLE • DELUXE GARDEN VIEWSGL.DX-GV

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    SINGLE DELUXE GARDEN VIEW

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–1 • Adults: max. 1 • Children: max. 0
    Room type
    SINGLE
    View / characteristic
    DELUXE GARDEN VIEW

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: SGL.DX-GV

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

  • DOUBLE SUPERIORDOUBLE • SUPERIORDBL.SU

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Bonefish Bay Motel

    DOUBLE SUPERIOR

    Room photos

    Photos are not available for this room type.

    Room overview

    Occupancy
    Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
    Room type
    DOUBLE
    View / characteristic
    SUPERIOR

    Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.

    Room code: DBL.SU

    Limited room details from hotel

    Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.

Guest reviews

What other guests saying about Bonefish Bay Motel

9.2
Excellent
665 Reviews
Cleanliness
9.6 /10
Service
9.4 /10
Comfort
8.8 /10
Condition
9.2 /10
Amenities
9.2 /10
100 reviews shown
10/10
Exceptional
06 Aug 2026
Heather
The room was clean and comfy and staff was very nice and helpful. This was our first time staying at Bonefish but we come to the Keys often and will definitely be staying again.
10/10
Exceptional
05 Aug 2026
Ahmed
It’s a very nice place
4/10
Poor
03 Aug 2026
Margaret
Upon checking out owner was confident that we had a pet with us and did not pick up after it. We did not have a pet and was charged $75.00 pet fee because maintenance guy said we did, it was the guest next to us that had pet.
8/10
Excellent
03 Aug 2026
Tien
We arrived late and checked in after the office was closed, but the staff left the room keys in the mailbox for us. The room was clean. However, when we heated breakfast in the morning, small roaches appeared in the kitchen area. We checked out early around 6AM, and the office was not open so that we could let the staff know about the roach issue.
10/10
Exceptional
28 Jul 2026
Hayley
Rooms were modern and up to date! Clean, cold and comfortable !!! Amenities were great! Our expectations were exceeded!! Great affordable stay for my family, we would stay again!
10/10
Exceptional
28 Jul 2026
Colleen
We loved the stay !
There was two parties in our stay we both booked the motel. However we got an upgrade to one of the family cabins and loved it ! Even with the staff washer not working while we were there, they still had plenty of towels for us !
The motel a/c was cold the room smelt a bit like water maybe too much humidity - but was clean ! The cabin the a/c runs hard but the Florida sun no joke def was a competition- the queen bed in front room and queen bed in back room - nice futon couch that falls down - the loft was massive but only had a twin mattress can def fit a bigger one up there- kitchen was stock and super cute on inside

the only down side to the property were the kayaks - there was three double kayak and all the seats were worn and torn two of them you could not even sit in the seat so basically you were holding your self up- only one single one but it was good condition-

The property is a great location as it’s in marathon middle to everything

We would def stay again !
10/10
Exceptional
25 Jul 2026
Eduardo
Beautiful team,and very comfortable rooms
10/10
Exceptional
21 Jul 2026
PETER
Bonefish Bay Motel has exceeded my expectations!! The staff were extremely friendly and helpful! The room was very clean, and recently remodeled! I enjoyed the amenities offered and the location in the Florida Keys is ideal! This is the best hotel!
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
14 Jul 2026
Zandra
We stayed at the Bonefish Motel and were genuinely impressed. We do not typically stay at motels, but this little gem exceeded our expectations and was better maintained than some four star hotels we have visited.

The room was extremely clean, thoughtfully arranged, and very comfortable. The beds and pillows were excellent, and the split air conditioning system kept the room at the perfect temperature without any issues. The kitchen was well stocked, and there was plenty of coffee available.

The location is also very convenient, especially if you are visiting the Key Colony area. This is a charming, well cared for property, and we would absolutely recommend giving it a try.
Family
6/10
Pleasant
13 Jul 2026
yaniselle
Very great staff Matience, Front Desk , Housekeepers were outstanding !!!! Definitely coming back next time .
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
09 Jul 2026
Victor
We stayed in the main building of the property. The room was spacious and well appointed including a hair dryer and kitchenette with microwave.They have free bikes and canoes available for guests. The ladies at reception were very helpful and nice. The place is close to the Marathon Lady docks where we took a fishing trip that was great fun. There is a pickle ball court, bbq and a pool. It was scorching hot so it would be nice if they planted more trees for greater shade. We had a nice stay- thank you!
Family
10/10
Exceptional
03 Jul 2026
Travis
What a great place. Clean room, nice pool. They have bikes and kayaks included in the stay. They also have a boat ramp and dock. Everything was easy and perfect 👌
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
27 Jun 2026
Loreta
Really nice place.
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
27 Jun 2026
Patrick
The room was very clean and looked freshly updated. Staff was extremely friendly.
Family_with_children
8/10
Excellent
22 Jun 2026
Blake
Convenient location. Housekeeping staff communication was a little lacking...nice clean outdoor pool. Kayak & bike rental included.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
21 Jun 2026
Roy
Love it here, great staff. Thank you Hannah for a great weekend
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
21 Jun 2026
Roy
Hannah saved my Father’s Day weekend. There was a hiccup with the room, Hannah not only made the problem go away, she gave my kids an amazing cabin and weekend. I have stayed here a bunch of times and will continue to come back! Best kept secret for boaters in marathon.

Thank you Hannah!
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
21 Jun 2026
Darcy
This place is a hidden gem in the Keys!! It was clean, well furnished, the staff was pleasant and they had great amenities! Saw several families playing pickleball, we enjoyed the pool and the chairs by the dock. Bathrooms were clean and well stocked, rooms were spacious. The beds in our room were a little tall, but some of the best hotel beds we’ve ever slept on! Wonderful stay, we will definitely be back!
10/10
Exceptional
19 Jun 2026
Melissa
Our family of four had a lovely time. The staff were great and the property was clean, well maintained and a prime location to access Marathon. The amenities, such as the pool, kayak access and Pickelball court were added perks which made the stay even more memorable. Highly recommend the Bonefish Motel!
10/10
Exceptional
12 Jun 2026
Christopher
Great stay. Clean. Staff very helpful. Bikes, kayaks. Fishing dock. We’ll be back next time in the Keys.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
11 Jun 2026
LLOYD
When I checked in the host was super friendly. The room was beautiful. The entire stop was much much better than I expected. I would recommend this Motel to anyone. they have rooms, cabins and an area for RV's. So very nice.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
08 Jun 2026
Arletis
Fue una estadía corta pero excekente
10/10
Exceptional
30 May 2026
Jenny
The room was very clean and comfortable. Appreciated the free use of kayaks. Dock area was ok but the water not as pretty there as in other parts of marathon. Pretty beaches were close by but has to pay to park. Overall, good value
Self
10/10
Exceptional
30 May 2026
kelly
we enjoyed it so much as a grown up trip we are coming back with the kids
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
28 May 2026
Heather
Very quiet place to relax, swim, take the boat out and fish. Grills, bikes and kayaks free to use. If bringing a boat call before booking to ensure you have a dock spot!
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
28 May 2026
Han
Everything is great there. The staff are friendly.
10/10
Exceptional
27 May 2026
Scott
The Bonefish Motel and RV park exceeded my expectations. My wife and I stayed in the motel, but there are also mobile cabins on site. The property was clean, rooms were large, and the location on Marathon Key was perfect. The pool was in good condition and it was fun to paddle around the cove on the complimentary kayaks.
Partner
8/10
Excellent
27 May 2026
Latisha
Overall- yes, I would definitely stay here again.

Pros: location was great- plenty of things to do and places to eat nearby. The place was very clean. My husband has a black light on his flashlight and checked out our room- it was incredibly clean. It was on the water and our son was easily able to fish. We didn’t use the kayaks because of the grass/ seaweed that washed up, but they were there and easily accessible. Check in was a breeze. We had a late check in- after midnight- and the staff emailed me letting me know exactly how to check in. The pool was nice too- very clean and deeper than most hotel pools. My son loved that bc he made friends with other kids doing cannonball contests.
Cons- there’s no curtain on the window and it’s very bright out. We ended up unscrewing our porch light and that helped some. The beds were squeaky but comfortable. The biggest complaint was the bathroom floor. It’s covered in large tiles that were mostly broken. It was incredibly squeaky and there was a ton of give if you stepped on them. It almost felt like the floor had soft spots.
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
24 May 2026
Tatum
I loved the location, the atmosphere, and the cleanliness od this place!
Family
2/10
Poor
21 May 2026
Mary
We only spent the night there. The thing that made my stay really bad was the theft of my jewelry that I left by accident. You see, we were heading to key west for a snorkeling trip so I took off my gold Hoop earrings, a gold rope chain with a gold and diamond cross, a gold box chain with a gold dolphin pendant and a gold Hilton Head Island map pendant, a gold bangle bracelet and a gold Anklet. I left them on the nightstand and didn't realize they were missing until we got back to Cocoa Beach that night and we unpacked.
I immediately called the next morning and the lady said she would check with housekeeping and call me back. She never called me back and we had to leave Florida so I called again. She said she talked to housekeeping and they said they didn't find anything. I say BS. Now they won't answer the phone.
10/10
Exceptional
19 May 2026
Ana
Everything was excellent! the staff, the room, and our whole stay!
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
18 May 2026
Kenneth M.
Professionally renovated, very clean, nicely decorated and convenient. Docks were also good.
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
15 May 2026
pamela
Loved it! Beautiful location on the water, great pool. Friendly staff. Clean!
Family
10/10
Exceptional
14 May 2026
William
The room was very clean and well maintained. The staff were kind, professional and very helpful. The hotel provided free kayak and bike rental. Will stay at this hotel again when I visit Key West in the future.
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
13 May 2026
Diane
Great location. Only 1 hour drive to Key West. There is a small kitchenette in the room with dishes, silverware, glasses, coffee maker, small fridge and microwave. Kayaks free of charge. We had to call for maintenance since we wanted to watch a certain football game on a Sunday and they came out right away and helped us. I’d stay here again!
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
13 May 2026
Jamie
The units and building have been recently remodeled. The unit was clean as was the pool. The kitchenette was stocked with paper towels, dish soap, sponge and dishes. The area around the pool is gorgeous with plumeria. There is kayaking available at no additional charge. If you need a ground floor unit, call to make sure what you are getting is not up a flight of steps.
10/10
Exceptional
06 May 2026
Spencer
Everything was better than we could have hoped for. Our family will absolutely be back when we visit the Keys.

They have free kayak rentals, pickle ball equipment, and a very nice pool!
10/10
Exceptional
05 May 2026
Jamie
This is an older property that has been renovated with improvements continuing to be made. We needed a grill and kitchenette and they have both. There are plenty of towels and the kitchenette had what you need to eat microwave food. Keurig coffee provided and something unheard of now, daily housekeeping! We’re loving it.
10/10
Exceptional
03 May 2026
Pierre
Clean room and comfortable bed
Pool is very nice and the staff is friendly and helpful
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
03 May 2026
Carrie
We absolutely loved our stay here and wished we could have stayed longer. Everything is as pictured, but even better in person. Highly recommend!
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
30 Apr 2026
Eric
My son and I stayed here on 04/29. We didn’t use much of the room due to FISHING!! But staff was very friendly, rooms were clean, bed was comfortable and the a/c was ice cold! I would definitely stay here again. The property also had cool looking cabins and boat rooms!
Friends_and_family Family
8/10
Excellent
30 Apr 2026
BIJU
Clean room
Family
10/10
Exceptional
29 Apr 2026
Matthew
Had a lovely stay at Bonefish. Lovely welcome and a lovely room. Was nice to also have access to to free kayaks to take out on the water. Highly recommend.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
25 Apr 2026
Joseph
Clean modern rooms in a great location.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
20 Apr 2026
Vivian
It was great!! Loved it!
10/10
Exceptional
19 Apr 2026
Jennie
Nice quiet location, food nearby, staff member was super friendly and helpful!
Partner
8/10
Excellent
19 Apr 2026
Thomas
Pool was nice. Rooms were very recently renovated so
couple of things were missing; hangars and a rod in the closet. would go back on my next trip.
Family
10/10
Exceptional
18 Apr 2026
Jorge
We only stayed overnight, but our room was very good, and we enjoyed the short term we stayed.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
15 Apr 2026
Bryan
The hotel is right on the water with access to the mangroves. The room was clean and spacious. The pool was refreshing after using the free kayaks. The owners were extremely friendly and welcoming.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
15 Apr 2026
Heather
Property is well kept
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
11 Apr 2026
Kate
Clean room. Proper kitchen amenities.
Friends_and_family Friends
6/10
Pleasant
09 Apr 2026
Seetaram Rao
Could not sleep
8/10
Excellent
07 Apr 2026
Enrique
Thank you we enjoyed our stay. Will beback again.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
05 Apr 2026
Gretchen
Property was clean and cozy .Staff was friendly and answered all my questions.
Family_with_children
4/10
Poor
05 Apr 2026
Timothy
The lady at the front desk was incredible! I did not book the room I thought that I had, and she helped me figure out sleeping arrangements. The motel was ok, but we had to kill 7 or 8 bugs that look like small cockroaches. I’m not sure what they were, but I should not have to kill bugs in my room like that. And a huge piece of tile was broken on the bathroom floor. All they have to do is put some mortar under it, and re-grout it.
10/10
Exceptional
02 Apr 2026
Diane
This was a beautiful place to stay. Highly recommended it. The cabins are cozy and new. They have house boats and hotel. The staff were great. I would stay there again. Thank you for the great hospitality.
Friends_and_family Friends
10/10
Exceptional
01 Apr 2026
Richard
This place offers so many options. We stayed in a very spacious motel room with a kitchen. They also had RV hookups, cabins, and even floating cabins. The kids loved the pickleball and swimming pool. The location was great. We stayed here two nights and drove to Key West, which was just over an hour away. If we return to the Keys, I will definitely stay here again. Great value and great location.
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
01 Apr 2026
Robert
Newly renovated room very clean and nice
10/10
Exceptional
31 Mar 2026
Rizwan
Amazing stay!
10/10
Exceptional
25 Mar 2026
pat
Very nice and clean. The staff was great and the mascot dog was very friendly.
10/10
Exceptional
24 Mar 2026
Dustin
Great place to stay
Family_with_children
8/10
Excellent
23 Mar 2026
Lydia
Room was clean and comfortable. Location was perfect for our trip of visiting the major keys.
10/10
Exceptional
23 Mar 2026
Susana
So far, this property exceeds my expectations in all levels.
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
21 Mar 2026
Jessica
Rooms were newly renovated. Clean, air conditioning and kitchenette. Property had a pool, fishing dock, cookout areas, pickle ball court.
Friends_and_family Family
8/10
Excellent
21 Mar 2026
Sarah
The property was fine for the amount we paid, it was clean and pleasant inside and in a good position with plenty of parking, however, the room smelt very musty and made all our clothes smell.
Partner
2/10
Poor
20 Mar 2026
Genevieve
The property is ideal for RV owners. We had booked for the hotel room which was really a motel. The room was dirty, there were pest control issues, and we were unable to sleep through the night. We are thankful the property refunded us for the 2 nights we had planned on staying. It was a very big disruption to our vacation plans.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
19 Mar 2026
Michael R.
Super clean and very enjoyable. Bikes, Kayaks, Pickleball, and chairs on the dock were all complimentary to use! So relaxing!
10/10
Exceptional
19 Mar 2026
Maya
Everything about it was very nice!
8/10
Excellent
17 Mar 2026
ASHLEY
.
10/10
Exceptional
16 Mar 2026
Camila
We had an amazing stay, the staff was very nice and welcoming, specially Misle. Definitely will come again!
10/10
Exceptional
15 Mar 2026
Roxana
El lugar está bonito las habitaciones están amplias y el lugar está muy limpio lo recomiendo
Family
10/10
Exceptional
15 Mar 2026
Pamuar
The room was spacious and clean. The motel is located in a great area. About an hour away from Key West!
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
14 Mar 2026
Alexander
The property was clean. Staff was friendly and very helpful. They have kayaks free for guest use and are directly on the water which was great. The pool was refreshing. I will definitely be coming back to stay.
8/10
Excellent
12 Mar 2026
Brett
Very nice room. 2 things would have made it great. More hooks or hangers for hanging wet clothes and a better shade over the window for the morning sun. Nice outdoor pool and kayaks, pickleball court and bikes for people to use.
10/10
Exceptional
12 Mar 2026
Ann
Very clean rooms. Rooms were large and spacious. Friendly staff. Would definitely stay here again.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
11 Mar 2026
Cindy
Therw are several types of accommodations and the staff was very friendly
Family
10/10
Exceptional
08 Mar 2026
Christopher
The best property and staff! We will return!
Family
10/10
Exceptional
08 Mar 2026
Frederick
The property itself exceeded our expectations, from the waterfront facilities to the motel room itself.
4/10
Poor
08 Mar 2026
Mark
The property grounds was good. Our room had mold and made me sick . Also the last day i got a bed bug bite on the back of my leg. The mold might be from leaks around the shower curtain.
Family
10/10
Exceptional
06 Mar 2026
Ernest
Nice place, good place to stop on the way to Key West
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
06 Mar 2026
Kevin
The room was very nice and clean. The property was as well. The staff in the office were so helpful and friendly going out of their way to make our travels easy.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
02 Mar 2026
Caeleigh
Clean room with all of the necessities. Plenty of space for our family of 4. The boys enjoyed the outdoor pool and the pickle ball court outside. We saw some really cool sea life from the docks and even caught a couple fish. Thank you for a wonderful stay! We will be back to use the free Kayaks next time!
Family_with_children
10/10
Exceptional
26 Feb 2026
Debra
We were in the two level rooms. Our room was up to date, extremely clean, quiet. Had everything we needed.

Kayaks, nice pool, pickleball court.
Plenty of parking.

Property access to the Bay. We took the kayaks out. Dolphins swimming with our Kayaks.

Easy access to local restaurants.
Partner
8/10
Excellent
20 Feb 2026
Ronald
Short office hours. No staff after 5 p.m. Wrong name with the key was left. Room was nice and clean
10/10
Exceptional
19 Feb 2026
Tristin
Very nice amenities and location. Room had everything we needed. Excellent for the price.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
18 Feb 2026
Katie
Quaint, low-key, not at all fancy but clean. Hard to find, no flashy sign. We were only there for the night but would have enjoyed the free kayaks. Interesting variety of lodging options. Very nice folks in the office. No coffee pods available.
Family
10/10
Exceptional
16 Feb 2026
Joseph
Room was clean and quiet. Great stay!
10/10
Exceptional
15 Feb 2026
Ellen
Great stay
10/10
Exceptional
12 Feb 2026
Jaye
Really cute little local hotel. Decor was cute and beach, kitchenette in the roo
10/10
Exceptional
10 Feb 2026
Mario
best ever
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
09 Feb 2026
Frank
Very nice
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
08 Feb 2026
donna
The room was large and spotless
The staff was friendly and very prompt to meet our needs. Alsi, a great location.
Partner
10/10
Exceptional
06 Feb 2026
Dan
Only stayed one night to go to the Turtle Hospital just down the road but our room was nice and clean. Staff was friendly and informitive.
Leisure Pet
10/10
Exceptional
03 Feb 2026
Mark
What a great place to stay. We stayed in motel and had 2 rooms. Both were super clean and had nice amenities
We will be back.
Leisure Friends
10/10
Exceptional
31 Jan 2026
Doreen
Everything was very good
10/10
Exceptional
29 Jan 2026
Timothy
A nice clean motel. Would definitely book there again.
10/10
Exceptional
29 Jan 2026
MITCHELL
We came after the office closed but our key and information were all ready for us.
Cute little motel, quiet, with ocean access, pool, pickleball court (with paddles and balls available) and kayaks.
Would come here again
Partner
8/10
Excellent
28 Jan 2026
Barbara
Clean room. Nice staff. Good location.
Leisure Friends
8/10
Excellent
27 Jan 2026
Valerie
The room was nice and clean
Friends_and_family Family
10/10
Exceptional
26 Jan 2026
Donna
Donia, John and Blaze are awesome!!!
Friends_and_family Family

Location & surroundings

Bonefish Bay Motel
12565 Overseas Highway, Marathon, United States

Hotels Nearby

Compare other stays close to this hotel. Choose travel dates to check availability.

Explore the map
Show 26 more nearby hotels

Bonefish Bay Motel

18 hotel photos