Name: Banana Bay Resort & Marina
Address: 4590 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, 33050, US

6/10

Pleasant

26 Jul 2026

YISEL

The person at the front desk is not very friendly they say they have towels and chairs for the beach when you go to the front desk to look they don't have and the broken ice machine they say they have it in the front desk when I was closed before the closing time for the rest good place clean very nice the big marina the pool

10/10

Exceptional

25 Jul 2026

William

Perfect!!

2/10

Poor

23 Jul 2026

ADRIA

El problema en este hotel esta en sus cargos ocultos cobran un resort fee completamente diferente que el que dice en la reserva; en adicion tambien cobran por parquear el trailer de un bote que ya esta pagando parqueo y eso no te lo dicen, es terrible, la verdad si van preparense para varios cobros inesperados

8/10

Excellent

20 Jul 2026

Jorge

Muy bueno para tener un bote e ir de pesca,relajarse frente al mar y habitaciones muy buenas,lo unico que no me gusto fue que el bar estaba cerrado y los precio de la marina y el parqueo estan demasiado caro,

Family

10/10

Exceptional

20 Jul 2026

David

Excellent pool

Self

4/10

Poor

19 Jul 2026

Elianne

The air conditioning was not working properly, all night long we had an uncomfortable hot air situation , the refrigerator was not working well, my opinion is that this hotel needs a remodeling because it needs a renovation to replace the old building and the old building needs replacing that old one.

Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

18 Jul 2026

Sharon

The room was clean and comfortable. The breakfast was skimpy; not too much food was offered, coffee was ok but no good creamers not very inviting. The back door was broken so we could not get out it, spoke to front desk and they sent a repair man, but he didn't fix it. The hotel advertised they had 2 Tiki bars, one by the pool and one by the water but neither one was open so that was disappointing. The pool was clean and refreshing! I was never informed that there was an additional charge to park your car at the hotel which I found completely INSANE, do they think you're going to walk there, the fee was $37.00 a night, UNBELEIVABLE!!!!! I could maybe understand if we brought more than 1 car but I feel if you pay for the room it should include at least 1 parking place

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

15 Jul 2026

Yvonne

My husband and I were very happy and pleased with everyone and everything. We can't wait to stay here again!

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

15 Jul 2026

Jennifer

Wonderful place to stay sunset out by the bar is amazing.. the only downfall was no elevator and I'm handicapped

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

14 Jul 2026

Joseph

Rooms only have double beds not actual queens. Found cockroaches in the bed. No bike rental as advertised. Pickle ball and tennis courts are not usable. Breakfast is just jimmy dean breakfast sandwiches and juice. Honestly when the pool was actually open was the best part. Would not stay again unless desperate.

Family_with_children

8/10

Excellent

13 Jul 2026

Deborah

The room was clean and there were plenty of towels and bathroom supplies. It was a good location close to restaurants. The staff was a little slow to check us in and find my reservation. The biggest complaint I have is the bathroom lighted mirror did not work and it’s too dark there and in the rest of the room. We’ve stayed here before and the mirrored light also did not work in another room either.

Family

4/10

Poor

13 Jul 2026

Holly

Very rundown, needs updating and breakfast was frozen jimmy dean sandwiches.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

13 Jul 2026

Elsa

Definitely will be staying here again

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

13 Jul 2026

YENSI acosta

Good

8/10

Excellent

12 Jul 2026

Elsa

Was very clean and have a kind staff

Friends

2/10

Poor

12 Jul 2026

Marlen

I arrived at the hotel at approximately 3:00 PM on July 11 but was told that I could not be checked in at that time. I informed the front desk representative that I was leaving for a fishing trip and would not return until after midnight. She assured me that my room key would be placed in a lockbox near the front office entrance so I could access my room when I returned.

When I arrived back at approximately 12:20 AM, the lockbox was completely locked, and I had never been provided with a code. I immediately called the hotel’s front desk number, but the representative was unable to provide the lockbox code, contact a manager, or offer any other way for me to access the room I had already paid for.

Because I was stranded outside the property in the middle of the night, I contacted law enforcement and made a police report regarding the incident. The sheriff also called the same hotel number and was told the same thing: the representative could not provide the code or connect us with a manager who could help.

As of 1:54 AM, I still had no access to my room and was forced to search for another hotel. I ultimately had to book a room at Fairfield Inn for more than $200, despite already having paid for the Banana Bay reservation through Expedia.

This situation was completely unacceptable, unsafe, and extremely distressing. I followed the hotel employee’s instructions, attempted to resolve the issue through the hotel’s listed number, and even involved law enforcement, so terrible!

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

07 Jul 2026

James

2nd time staying here and I have two main complaints that will probably keep me from returning.
1st, spoke to the reservation person, paid for an extra night as our family would be arriving at 2am to get a jump on our weekend stay. I told the rep that we would be in around 2am and he said it would be fine, we arrived at 2 and no key, No one at the office. The 4 of us had to sleep in the car until 7am. The person at the front desk refunded that night and let us check in early but after a 7 hour drive and sleeping in the car our 1st day was shot.
2nd, person taking our reservation told us amenities included bbq grills, website also states that, asked the front desk where they were located and spent 20min trying to find them only to be told later that they no longer offered grills. I had brought a bunch of meats in a cooler as well as my sister who was also staying there and the plan was to bbq with our two families for 4th of July. We ended up buying ice throughout the trip to keep the meets from going bad.

6/10

Pleasant

07 Jul 2026

Yurly

El staff muy servicial, el desayuno muy malo deberían tener más opciones , la habitación sucia

Friends

6/10

Pleasant

05 Jul 2026

Mislena

There was an annoying sound all night I think from the AC. Check our room 336 bc it’s super annoying that sound all night. One of the night lights did not work, to get ice you have to go downstairs. The noise AC, last time the TV was in Spanish mode and super complex just to find a local channel.

2/10

Poor

02 Jul 2026

Corrynne

The room was dirty , the initial front desk secretary had no idea what she was doing , said she was new and overcharged me. Told me to fix it in the morning when someone was at work that knew the correct prices. The “bartender” was on a personal call on speakerphone instead of serving guests. When you walked up to the bar she said “we’re out of everything except soda “ before you said anything to her. The manager on site was helpful the next morning when I got the charges sorted but the damage had already been done. Will never be returning this hotel. Both rooms we got switched to smelled like mold and cigarettes.

Partner

4/10

Poor

02 Jul 2026

Amanda

While we appreciated the opportunity to stay at Banana Bay, we were disappointed that several of the amenities included in the daily resort fee were either unavailable or did not meet the descriptions provided at the time of booking.

Specifically:

Sunset Bar: On our first evening, the Sunset Bar was not operating. Instead, the bartender remained inside the closed building while loudly carrying on a phone conversation for more than an hour. Several families came to enjoy the sunset but ultimately left because of the disturbance.

Complimentary Bikes: When I inquired about using the bicycles that were advertised as being included with the resort fee, I was informed that only one bike was available for guests.

Housekeeping: During our three-day stay, our room was not serviced. As a result, we were left with damp towels and ran out of basic amenities, including shampoo and coffee.

Because we were charged a daily resort fee, I expected the amenities associated with that fee to be available and delivered as advertised. Unfortunately, that was not our experience.

6/10

Pleasant

01 Jul 2026

Don

The lodging was well situated so making early morning fishing trips easy enough. The in room refrigerator was way too small, with no freezer. The included breakfast began at 8:00 way too late for us as most fishing trips begin at 8:00. Fortunately there was a restaurant nearby that opened at 6:00.

Family

8/10

Excellent

01 Jul 2026

Gordon

The main building where our harbour view room was, was lovely, new, spotless. Very nice. The breakfast area and some other areas were a little tired. The pier view is spectacular at sunset. The bar opens 6 till 9 although was closed on our first night. Location great. No food on site after breakfast but plenty of nearby spots to dine. Hurricane was good pub and food.

Family_with_children

2/10

Poor

29 Jun 2026

christopher

Horrible experience at this so-called “resort.” The photos are clearly outdated and do not reflect the current condition of the property.The pool was in terrible shape, with broken concrete around the pool edges and deck. There were no towels available, and the pool restroom was out of order.The rooms were spacious and the beds were comfortable, but cleanliness was a major issue. The sofa, headboard, and bed frame were all stained. The bathroom was missing the shower door, causing water to flood the floor after every shower, and there were hairs everywhere. It did not appear to have been properly cleaned.The lobby looked clean, but the hallways were a completely different story. The carpets were stained, and there was trash throughout the hallways. The room doors had large gaps around them with no sound or air insulation, so you could hear everything happening in the hallway. People started making noise as early as 6:00 a.m., making it impossible to sleep.Breakfast was very basic and not what was advertised. It was definitely not a buffet. The options included Jimmy Dean sausage and egg sandwiches that had to be microwaved, frozen muffins, yogurt, coffee, and juice. The breakfast area itself was old and not very clean.The location is good, and the staff was friendly, but unfortunately that does not make up for the poor condition of the property or justify the price. I’m not someone who usually leaves negative reviews, but this experience left me with no choiceNot recommended!

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

27 Jun 2026

Nicholas

Great stay

4/10

Poor

26 Jun 2026

sandy

It’s not a resort it’s more an overpriced hotel. When we booked it we were told it would be an additional $118 when we arrived, upon arrival we were charged $226. There was no poolside bar they have a” bar “ by the marina that’s supposed to be open from 5-11 it was only open for about 3 hours one day. There was no buffet breakfast their breakfast consisted of thawed frozen breakfast sandwiches to heat up in the microwave, stale coffee, & out of date yogurt. The pool was ok but definitely needs to be updated as there were pieces falling off. There’s no elevator

Partner

2/10

Poor

26 Jun 2026

yurixander

Everything

8/10

Excellent

25 Jun 2026

Nayara

Room was great!
Staff was friendly, pool area was taken over by loud guests to say the least and due to no other swimming areas available at the property that was a negative for us.
Breakfast could use a few more options, but overall a great stay!

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

24 Jun 2026

María

Todo estába bien , muy limpio y con muy buen olor

Partner

2/10

Poor

23 Jun 2026

Alain

The staff the marine it's very bad 👎

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

23 Jun 2026

Alain

The marine it's good the staff the marine it's horrible sara it's really bad 👎 the price the marine is very expensive

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

22 Jun 2026

Mandi

What a beautiful resort. Everything was great!!!!!!!

Friends

10/10

Exceptional

22 Jun 2026

Dainerys

Great place to come with friends and family.

Family_with_children

8/10

Excellent

21 Jun 2026

Karenia

Our overall experience at the hotel was very good. The rooms were clean, the facilities were well maintained, and most of the staff were friendly and attentive. The location and amenities made our stay very enjoyable.

Unfortunately, our experience at the marina was very different. The service provided by the marina manager, Sara, was disappointing and unprofessional. We felt that we were treated differently from other guests and perceived an unwelcoming attitude toward our group, which made the experience uncomfortable and unpleasant.

It is also important to mention that guests bringing their boats should be aware of the marina fee of approximately $180 per day, which can be quite expensive.

It is unfortunate that the service at the marina does not reflect the same level of quality and hospitality that we experienced throughout the rest of the hotel. I hope management addresses these concerns to improve the experience for future guests.

Friends_and_family Family

2/10

Poor

21 Jun 2026

Xuedi

Very disappointing experience. The hotel was extremely dark and uninviting. To make matters worse, they charged a daily parking fee that was never clearly disclosed during the booking process.

The marina fees are outrageously expensive, and on top of that, they charge separately for trailer parking while the hotel charges again for vehicle parking. The extra fees never seem to end.

The service was inconsistent as well. One day we were told that ice was complimentary, and the next day we were charged for it. The breakfast was by far the worst hotel breakfast I have ever had—poor quality and very limited options.

Overall, this place feels like it finds every possible way to charge guests extra. Between the hidden fees, excessive marina costs, double parking charges, poor breakfast, and lack of transparency, the entire experience was a complete disaster. I would not recommend this hotel to anyone.

Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

21 Jun 2026

Barbara

Room was not ready at 4:30pm, hotel needs maintenance

4/10

Poor

21 Jun 2026

Gissell

Resort fee 35$ a night and you dont even get pool towels. For people with boats
220$ per night to keep a 22ft boat in the water , in addition to $75 per night to park the trailer, 15$ to use the “ramp” ANDDDDD 18$ per night to park the car. So for 2 nights $641.00 in addition to the hotel price.
So if you have a boat, get ready to pay .
The pool is old and no staff, no towels, dirty bathroom. Pool water was so hot it felt your were in a soup getting cooked.
Room was okay, 3 of 4 light switches didnt work. A/C was cold ( i guess thats a plus) however so loud could barely sleep.
Ceiling fan didnt work . Toilet wouldn’t fill the water tank when you flushed.
Overall not a nice stay at all. Will never stay at this “resort” ever again.
Ice machine didnt work - had to paid $8 for a bag of ice at the front desk.

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

20 Jun 2026

Yaney

Nwbwjwjwjjejwjwjwj

10/10

Exceptional

18 Jun 2026

Judith

We stayed here for a fishing trip that was truly a trip of a lifetime. The staff was great, cleaning around us while we spent the next day preserving the catch through our food saver vacuum system.
I was pleased to see the laundry area was very close to our room, but surprised no soap was available, even for sale. I asked at the front desk, thinking they would have some to buy, and by that time our room smelled of our fishy clothes. They didn't have any soap either! We put our clothes in a trash bag out on our deck and washed them many times at home. I think the staff would find it helpful to have several single sized laundry soap for sale at the front desk.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

16 Jun 2026

Margaret

The pool is beautiful and rooms are cute and clean.
Conveniently located by everything we wanted to do…sombrero beach, Turtle rescue hospital, brass monkey, dockside etc

Friends

6/10

Pleasant

15 Jun 2026

Dailet

Overall the place was okay, however, breakfast is very limited and not continental as advertised. Additionally, the bar never opened during my stay. Other than that, the place was great!

Family

10/10

Exceptional

14 Jun 2026

Sean

This was a great place to land for the night during my vacation to the keys! good cleanliness and a unique property on the water.

Self

10/10

Exceptional

14 Jun 2026

Howard

Was well worth the $$

10/10

Exceptional

14 Jun 2026

Maria

The staff were super friendly and helpful. The room was kept clean, and was very spacious!

Self

6/10

Pleasant

08 Jun 2026

Brian

I've stayed here for a number of years and the property appears to be slipping. At check in they were training a new employee and their computer went down for 15 minutes, so it took a while to get checked in. The staff was very polite. The A/C in the room didn't cool completely.

The rooms don't have true refrigerators, they have chillers which do an ok job but aren't as cold as a fridge. The ice machines in both buildings were broken and when I asked the staff if I could get some ice from the kitchen I was told they didn't have ice there either.

I know it's standard with Expedia and other booking services to pay a base rate and then have to pay additional fees at the resort, but it was hard to determine what these fees were this year, and the daily resort fee was increased this year, as was parking, which aded an additional 50 dollars a day to the deal I thought I was getting on Expedia.

If you're looking for a minimalist room for a fishing trip or something (why I book this property) this still fits the bill but be aware of the additional fees and the fact that the property is slipping some.

Self

6/10

Pleasant

04 Jun 2026

Lindsay

The room was good with comfy beds. We couldn’t get the room to cool down though so it was a bit warmer than we would have liked. The shower sprays everywhere outside the shower stall so we needed towel to mop it up. I ended up with glass in my foot at the pool but the pool was enjoyable other than that. The breakfast was lacking. It was frozen breakfast sandwiches or a prepackaged muffin. I don’t think I would call that a continental breakfast. Probably wouldn’t stay here again.

Family_with_children

4/10

Poor

04 Jun 2026

Elaine

We were met at check-in with exorbitant parking fees and additional resort fees that were not listed on the website. The breakfast was the worst we have ever experienced especially after being charged such high fees. The room, however, was very nice and the only saving grace.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

03 Jun 2026

Tami

Clean room, nice TP!

Partner

4/10

Poor

01 Jun 2026

Jeffrey

The website was misleading. There was no bar out by the pool. The bar by the oceanfront was supposed to serve food according to the website, but it didn’t. It was only open from 5 to 8. The room had a really bad smell coming out of the air conditioner which maintenance tried to fixed by cleaning the filter, but they just sprayed stuff in it to make it smell fruity for about a day then it went away and went back to the smell. I was there for six nights, smelling it the drain in the bathroom in the shower. Also had a terrible smell coming from it so I will not be going back to the banana day. also, I forgot that they charge you $19 a day for parking which I thought was ridiculous because they weren’t even over booked so there was plenty of parking. It seemed to me like it’s just another way to get more money.

Friends

6/10

Pleasant

30 May 2026

Robert

Would

6/10

Pleasant

29 May 2026

Crystal

It's needs an update. There wasn't a microwave. Pool is nice and was open after hours. The “buffet” was what they advertised. It was just muffins and Jimmy Dean sandwiches and My daughter grabbed expired yogurt. So there's that.

Partner

2/10

Poor

28 May 2026

Ariadna

I don’t recommend it, they said breakfast included but it doesn’t, you have to pay 💰, they try to charge me more things than I don’t want without explanation. They charge you parking and doesn’t have a proper space for parking, they are small and uncomfortable.

Family_with_children

4/10

Poor

26 May 2026

Mislena

The telephone to call reception does not work, the tv channels available are the most basic, not even showing the local channels…..we paid for two nights and left after the first night. Did not even bother to ask for a refund.

6/10

Pleasant

26 May 2026

Kim

We were very disappointed that there was no bar on site. No activities like their website suggested. The only amenity that we used was the pool and the only other one they had on the property was tennis courts and pickleball courts. We would probably not stay here again.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

25 May 2026

Maria Aurora

Me gustó el paisaje

Pet

10/10

Exceptional

25 May 2026

Odeimys

Excellent

2/10

Poor

24 May 2026

Gabrielle

I owned a business for 27 years, so I always try to look at things from that perspective. I book rooms that specifically state that they have an in room refrigerator because I am a diabetic and need to store my insulin. The description as on the Expedia website clearly stated that there was a refrigerator ( I took a screen shot), there was a cooler in the space for the refrigerator. I went into panic mode and was told by the staff that was all they had. My husband spent time away from our vacation refilling the cooler with ice to keep my insulin cold. Our stay was for 4 nights, 2 of those days we did not have hot water. Told by the staff that the pipes to our building were really old and we would have to let the water run for a very long time. We did such, still no hot water. Day 3 I summoned the maid from the hall because there was all this dust around the table and tv stand, she immediately identified this as termite dust. Reported such to the management and they said they would spray immediately! The next day, even more termite dust, they did not spray. I have never one time in my extensive travels written a negative review. This was my breaking point. Expedia needs to check and then check again about what they write. On occasions like this, my life was at stake.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

23 May 2026

Teresa

We were provided a Keurig coffee machine, but the staff never replaced coffee. We shopped Winn Dixie close by for coffee. Added an unknown parking fee per night. The breakfast time was only 2 hours, wished it had been longer. Our encounter with the Sunset Lounge for cocktails was beer or wine but the view was as amazing

Friends

8/10

Excellent

20 May 2026

Andraine

This hotel was a good place to lay your head. It seems like most folks come here to just lay their head because their main goal is to go fishing. The amenities themselves were pretty cool. The pool is nice (I wish the pool bar was actually operating), and the paradise bar place has fun games and a beautiful view. The only thing I didn’t like was the breakfast. It was just the frozen Jimmy Dean breakfast sandwiches, little bites muffins, and chobani yogurt (which was a bit concerning because there were no expiration dates). All in all, I wouldn’t avoid this place.

Family_with_children

2/10

Poor

20 May 2026

Bessy

I honestly dont like to give bad reviews but this hotel was a huge disappointment. I really researched this place through their IG page, and Expedia page and the way they promote this resort is NOTHING compared to how it looks on social media. First and foremost we stayed for 1 night with me and my family and it was OVERLY priced. We booked this resort with the expectation of the bar being inside, the pool, tennis court and the \"free breakfast\". The resort itself was dirty. Tennis court was dirty. And the bar was closed. The breakfast was the most disappointing as it was PACKED SANDWICHES from the gas station across the street. Sunday morning we saw a cockroach in the bathroom. However, there's a bar close by that was actually walking distance and was open till 4AM which we had a good time. But other than that this place does not look like anything at all from their social media, website, or Expedia.

Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

15 May 2026

Lisandra

the room were well made but not clean it was dusty in the room and he drawers to the dresser were broken . the towels are very small not at all adult size pleasing. the bathrooms only have one glass door and by the time your done showering your bathroom floor is flooded as well. also keep in mind when you get there they ask. \" are you aware of the extra resort fee?\" \"are you aware of the parking payment every night ?\" and I am just like well no but I guess I know now!!
for a night stay is not bad but I wouldn't rent here for a whole weekend or week on vacation with my family.

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

15 May 2026

Felix

Very clean new hotel the pool was very big kids had a great trip!

Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

14 May 2026

Tammy

Very nice room. Could not locate ice machine or anyone who could assist me.

Self

8/10

Excellent

11 May 2026

Sonia

The room was clean. Staff was very pleasant and welcoming. Bar and Amennities were poor. The resort has a lot of potential but it needs a lot of attention

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

10 May 2026

Terry

Room was very clean comfortable. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Breakfast was pitiful!

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

10 May 2026

Cristobal

Ok

10/10

Exceptional

09 May 2026

Lori

I didnot like those big lizards everywhere.
Everything else was great.

Partner

4/10

Poor

09 May 2026

Chris

You have to pay $20 a day to park your car at their location.
There’s a $35 fee for access to the pool, hot tub and breakfast areas that you cannot opt out out of.
The breakfast consist of premade muffins, orange juice, milk, and cereal.

I would not recommend this establishment.

Partner

2/10

Poor

09 May 2026

Vanessa

The front desk was helpful during check-in, but our room was completely dirty when we arrived. We called the office before 11 pm, but there was no response. The room had dirty pillowcases, bed sheets, and a bathroom sink covered in dead bug wings. The toilet had pee stains and hair, and there were dirty hand marks on the walls. Despite the resort’s nice and coastal appearance, this room was a complete letdown.

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

07 May 2026

Leyxoe

Me encanto muy limpio y tranquilo 100%
Recomendado

Pet

6/10

Pleasant

07 May 2026

James

Nice little hotel. Room was nice and clean modern. Breakfast was quite poor as we are from UK and its not what we would have for breakfast. We had to pay for Parking which we knew about when we got there but we also got a hotel charge added when we got there which was $35 which we weren't expecting to pay and not sure what it was for, so that was a bit disappointing. Ok place to rest our heads for the night.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

06 May 2026

Dolores

Fine

Partner

2/10

Poor

05 May 2026

Isbel

Nothing to do at this hotel

Partner

4/10

Poor

04 May 2026

Timothy

Resort fee per day that was not visibly worth it. ..pool area needed some significant TLC.
Daily parking fee even for those staying at hotel.
Extremely lack luster breakfast that was only available 8-10am.
No microwave in room.
No on site grill.
No swimming area other than pool.

Friends_and_family Family

4/10

Poor

01 May 2026

Leonid

Do not be fooled by the \"resort\" label. This place is a glorified 2-star motel with a predatory pricing model.We paid $300 per night only to be given a room with a depressing view of the parking lot—which, by the way, they charged us an additional $19 per day just to use.The \"included breakfast\" was an insult. There were no eggs, no bagels, and shockingly, no coffee. Instead, they served frozen sandwiches that looked like they were bought in bulk from a dollar store.Save your money and stay elsewhere. Paying premium prices for bottom-of-the-barrel service and views is a total scam. Avoid at all costs.

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

30 Apr 2026

diane

Nice place to lay your head. Quiet.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

27 Apr 2026

Jessy

El area del tiki bar tiene una vista Maravillosa del atardecer

Family_with_children

6/10

Pleasant

27 Apr 2026

Traci

The property and staff were fine. The rooms were very clean. There was a constant smell of pot in our hallway and the pool bar was never open. Breakfast needs to be stepped up. The resort fee is unreasonable.

Friends

4/10

Poor

27 Apr 2026

Ismael

This hotel has really gone downhill in terms of quality. I used to stay here regularly, but now the bathrooms are dirty, the towels are stained with lipstick, there isn't even a microwave in the room, and the refrigerator barely cools anything! All in all, I don't know why this hotel has declined so much.

Friends

2/10

Poor

27 Apr 2026

James

We had a confirmation to stay.Credit card was charged. Had no rooms in the area. Had to sleep in the car.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

25 Apr 2026

Tiffany

Everything good. Room pool hot tub amenities. Bar needs to be open at sunset

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

24 Apr 2026

Craig

Very clean and beautiful place to relax!

8/10

Excellent

20 Apr 2026

Pam

We loved the place. We just wish we could have had a better beach area.
Pool area was good.
Nice big pool
Breakfast was good
Rooms were nice, clean and everything worked
Staff was great

Friends

10/10

Exceptional

20 Apr 2026

Scott

Very quiet, clean, nice rooms with a view of the water

Friends

8/10

Excellent

20 Apr 2026

Hide

The staff were super friendly in the office. Breakfast is super basic, 3 cereal options, frozen sausage and egg sandwiches, coffee, milk, yogurt and OJ. The pool & hot tub were nice. The bar is super basic, but nice view of the Gulf. Next to hotel is a nice bar and restaurant that had live music when we went there on a Thursday night. We used the 2 free loaner bikes to ride to the 7-mile bridge. The bikes were in good condition, can tell someone maintains them regularly given the use they get. It was nice the staff will also loan you locks to use with bikes. Would book again, and request the building by the Marina, I think that building is a little nicer than the one by the office. Also used the coin-operated laundry, which was super convenient because the laundromat in town does not have reliable hours. Great location in the keys if you want a place more laid back than Key West.

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

19 Apr 2026

Michael

The grounds are beautiful. Very peaceful place. I really enjoyed staying here and would highly recommend

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

19 Apr 2026

Stacy

Good location, but room smelled like mold/ mildew. Bathroom vanity has major water damge .You could not even close the door. Couch in the room looked dirty. Toilet had issues with not flushing properly and Ac unit made some strange noises. You also get charged extra for resort fees. I got motel vibes not resort.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

17 Apr 2026

Anusha

property was clean. well kept.
however, in our 4 day stay only 1 day the house keeping arrived, all other 3 days house keeping never arrived. we ended up with dirty rooms sheets and no towel. had to run each day to front desk after long tired day under the sun, for fresh towels.
you are in bad luck with drying wet swimsuits if you got the room with no balcony. resort could have a swimsuit spin dry machine for convenience.
the bar in the property was in a great location, however it was never open for the entire duration of our stay. front desk tells you that the bar will be open till 6pm-10 pm. friendly staff. breakfast provided was the most pathetic spread we had ever experienced. no basic bread, toaster, jam, pancakes, syrup, honey or fruits.

Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

13 Apr 2026

george

We like the banana bay. I would return when we get back to the keys

10/10

Exceptional

13 Apr 2026

Jennifer

The building our room is in and the room itself was very clean, and the property very quiet and well kept. We will be back in a month

10/10

Exceptional

13 Apr 2026

Frank

Great property with great amenities and great location. Breakfast was very basic and could use some fresh fruit or more protein option. Overall a great place!

8/10

Excellent

12 Apr 2026

Wendy

Clean and near. Missed opportunities with outside bar and outside bar staff

2/10

Poor

11 Apr 2026

mark

Room had a terrible Urine smell, Resort has hidden fees. Beware

Self

8/10

Excellent

10 Apr 2026

Angela

It was a positive experience

Family

10/10

Exceptional

08 Apr 2026

Sandra

Staff especially front desk was very accommodating. They should disclose that parking and resort fees are not included in price!

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

08 Apr 2026

Heidi

It’s an older place. Our hotel was farther away from the water. Ice machine didn’t work. No one at tiki bar. Overall mediocre but just a place to crash.

8/10

Excellent

07 Apr 2026

Verified traveler

Ok

4/10

Poor

04 Apr 2026

Brooke

The rooms are the only plus. They are clean. The breakfast consist of one kind of cereal and frozen breakfast sandwich you microwave. The property is really run down and the bar is not open when they report the hours

Family

8/10

Excellent

03 Apr 2026

Andrew

Great pier area and water view.
Nice that use of bikes included although we did not use.
Great location half way along the keys.

Friends_and_family Friends

6/10

Pleasant

31 Mar 2026

Kyle

The room was actually nice, but this is not a resort dont let that fool you. The buffet breakfast is a joke it might have yogurt it might not, best thing is they have microwavable Jimmy dean sausage biscuits awesome. Also they say this magnificent buffet is only for two people and you you need to pay $11.95 for additional participants. You might as well cruise down the street to mickie dees. Also watch out for the marina Karen. Hey if youre looking for a base of operations in the middle keys this probably isn't the worst option out there. Back to the marina Karen we saw the cops there 3 times for her dire needs in the 4 days we had the privilege of staying.

Family_with_children