Plymouth Inn

United States , Appleton - WI
Plymouth, 606 E Mill St Po Box 512
Show on Google | Map

20 reviews shown

10/10

Exceptional

11 May 2026

Joseph

Clean, fresh remodel, Comfy bed, nice accommodations!

Friends_and_family Friends

2/10

Poor

15 Mar 2026

Ryan

Could not figure out how to get into room, no receptionist to check you in. Have to make separate arrangements directly with owner ahead of time.

10/10

Exceptional

14 Mar 2026

Mary

Coffee cup lids would be helpful.
Different hand soap .
Greatly appreciated full refrigerator so we could keep our ice packs frozen.

10/10

Exceptional

10 Mar 2026

Nicole

All questions were quickly answered via text. Staff was very prompt! Room was nice and clean. The beds were very comfy.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

28 Feb 2026

Dawn

Clean room, the staff the property was easy to find. Our room was amazing.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

03 Jan 2026

Gary

I did not include pricing/rate info, personal info or use profanity; yet you refused to publish my review. Perhaps it wasn't positive enough. Makes me wonder how much I can trust the reviews you do publish. I will be avoiding Hotels.com in the future. Upon arriving in the \"lobby\" there was a notice that this is 'a \"Self Service\" hotel, like an Airbnb.' I did not notice anything stating such during the booking process. The suite was clean and spacious, but the only heat was in the MBR which did not transfer very well to the rest of the suite. The bathroom is inconveniently located on the opposite end of the suite as the bedrooms. in addition to the shower being extremely small, the complex controls were a bother while the relatively simple soap dispensers didn't work.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

02 Jan 2026

Jacob

Very nice, newly remodeled place!

Very walkable in the heart of downtown Plymouth but also has plenty of free parking.

Road America is a quick jaunt down the highway (maybe 5 miles or so.)

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

01 Jan 2026

Thomas

Easy checkin

Leisure Partner

8/10

Excellent

28 Dec 2025

Dwight

Yes yes

4/10

Poor

20 Dec 2025

Christine

Couldn't get in the room, sent to a different room with king size bed for 3 adults and 1 child. Finally got to a room withtwo beds and the Curtains didn’t close all the way. 2 towels for 4 people. No tv. Then they said they would send someone to fix the tv but no one showed up.

10/10

Exceptional

10 Dec 2025

Lee

Beautiful room and fantastic price!

Friends_and_family Friends

6/10

Pleasant

05 Dec 2025

Theresa

Bathroom door don't shut. Hinge is coming off of top of door.

8/10

Excellent

05 Oct 2025

Ned

Close to bars with food or without. Easy phone code check in.

Friends_and_family Friends

2/10

Poor

09 Sep 2025

Katie

This hotel was bought out and is being turned into an Airbnb hotel. The property looked decent, You walk into the lobby and it looks pretty, however, since an Airbnb setting there are no staff on site and the front door is always unlocked with no security. We were supposed to stay for one night so we stopped and dropped off our bags. Theyre in the process of updating which is good because the rooms are out of date and the furniture has wear. The rooms weren’t the cleanest but it was just for one night. We did have a stain on one of our pillow cases on the other bed but again no one around to ask for anything. The huge negative about this property is apparently all the rooms have the same code. I was there with my parents who were in a different room, aunt and uncle in a different room and my cousins with their two young kids in another. We all had the same code to our rooms. My parents got sick so they weren’t able to make it. When the rest of my family including myself got to the hotel to go to our rooms they were occupied by other peoples belongings. I checked my parents room since mind you we had the same code they had bags sitting on their beds with other peoples stuff. Now if those were reserved for us how did other people get those rooms also especially since there were plenty of other rooms that could’ve been used. The staff clearly doesn’t know what they are doing and we all felt so unsafe that we drove back home. I did contact the company and we weren’t charged.

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

07 Sep 2025

chris

Nice room clean. Looked new better than expected. It was different with no employee there. Only thing i had a question about was check out? We just left and figured it was automatic cause we were gone before checkout time.

Leisure Family

2/10

Poor

07 Sep 2025

Robert

I would not recommend this Hotel at all.

First of all there was no success at calling and talking to a customer service rep to confirm my reservations for two rooms. I was sent a confirmation via email a couple of days before our scheduled stay. Then I received two text messages in the morning of the day of our scheduled stay.
The text messages listed which rooms we were assigned. Along with the room numbers was included a 4 number code for each room. It turned out both rooms had the same check in code. When we arrived at the hotel to check in the front door to the Hotel was wide open. There was no check in clerk. We walked up to the second floor with our luggage because there was no elevator. I put the code into the first room we were assigned. The door unlocked and opened up. I turned on the light and was shocked to see One of the two beds was unmade, there was somebody's clothes laying on top of that bed, a left over fast food meal, and a duffle bag and gym shoes on a chair. I went to the other room, put in the same code I was given for that room, opened the door, turned on the light, and even though the one bed was made there some luggage on the chair. Based on all that along with some other details, we decided to not stay and drive back home to the Chicago area which was a 2 plus hour drive home at night which we were trying to avoid.

Friends_and_family Family

8/10

Excellent

25 Aug 2025

jim

keyless lock entry

10/10

Exceptional

25 Aug 2025

Dan

Great place in down town.

Freshly rehab'd room, so new, the microwave still had packing in it. Looking to book for the 2026 SCCA events at the nearby track. Check-in was way to easy. Other rooms are either re-done or about to be, in the immediate future.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

22 Aug 2025

David

It was just okay...

Non traditional checkin process made checking in difficult with no staff on site. Locks on door did not want to lock and took multiple attempts. Looked like very clean room with the exception of 1 roach. In room refrigerator was very loud and had to unplug.

Business

10/10

Exceptional

18 Aug 2025

Luis

Booking a room is not listed in walk up directions, took some internet research to figure out & a phone call to get our door code & room number.

Rep sent my booking to my friend’s phone not mine causing some confusion on both our part. This process could be improved.

Leisure Friends