The Surf Lodge

United States , New York Area - NY
MONTAUK, 183 Edgemere St
Show on Google | Map

20 reviews shown

10/10

Exceptional

01 Aug 2025

Theodor Cristian

Great experience overall!

10/10

Exceptional

08 Sep 2021

agata

Great hotel, bad restaurant experience

Simple but beautiful accommodations, room very clean. Loved that the mini bar is complimentary and the balcony overlooking the water was so peaceful! Their outside beach/bar area is amazing.
The only bad experience we had was at the hotel restaurant. We had a reservation for a special pop up dinner and not only were we ignored by the staff for 15 minutes, it took over an hour to seat us and then we had to flag down a waiter after 20 minutes just sitting at our table to get a drink. Then we were told that they were out of 3 of the 4 main entrees on a prix fix menu. They offered us chicken tenders and a discount instead which would have still been 65$. For chicken tenders! Turns out the host allowed 55 walk ins and knew they were out of food when he sat us 45 minutes late. By then it was too late to get food anywhere else and they tried to send us to another place that they said was serving late only to find their kitchen closed too! What we thought was going to be nice fancy dinner ended up with take out burritos on our balcony.
They did make it better the next day by inviting us for some complimentary apps and drinks but that was after we complained to the manager and communicated with him all day about our experience. Overall, great hotel but due to the lack of organization at their restaurant, I would eat somewhere else.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

06 Aug 2021

Verified traveler

property was awesome, food was great, staff great, etc.
would have liked soap and hand sanitizer in the room tho but other than that all good

Leisure Partner

6/10

Pleasant

28 Jul 2021

Verified traveler

I was dying to stay at the iconic surf lodge for their great live music, excellent food and boho chic decor while spending the week surfing in Montauk. I asked the hotel for a beach pass so I could park with ease at the permit required lots of Ditch Plains and the woman at the front desk gave me what I thought was the beach parking pass which I used for 3 days at the beach. On the third day I received a $150 parking ticket and when I complained to the manager of the hotel, Erika, she said that I had been given the wrong parking pass by the front desk and should have received a different pass and needed to ask her manager what to do. Please note that there is no way to communicate with anyone here unless you email them and hope for a response. I emailed the Director of Operations, Ben, about the unfortunate incident and he snidely responded with “we will not be taking on the parking expenses” even though it was clearly their error. After spending $625/night I can honestly say I will never stay here again. Not to mention the bathroom still had a dirty wash cloth on top of the shower head upon our arrival. We didn’t make a big deal about it but should have in hind sight. Also, the walls are paper thin and you can hear just about everything.

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

17 Jul 2021

Verified traveler

The room was just as advertised with super friendly and accommodating staff

Leisure Family

4/10

Poor

01 Jul 2021

Verified traveler

sad how run down the property seemed. Totally overpriced for condition and amenities

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

27 Oct 2020

Andrea

Amazingly relaxing stay. Not the usual surf lodge party vibe due to COVID, but they did a beautiful job with the room reservations and the private balcony with hammock overlooking the lake made for a much needed

Partner

8/10

Excellent

13 Oct 2020

Lauren

When we walked into our room we instantly smelt the cleanliness and efforts of the cleaning staff. We felt at ease knowing our room was safe and clean. We absolutely LOVED that the surf lodge was dog friendly. You would never even know it because the room and decor was in great shape, including the bed which was so comfortable! We especially loved our patio and shower. The sound of the lake waves were extremely relaxing and the shower we didn't want to get out of. It was a great addition that everything in the mini bar was free (or included in your stay), we enjoyed that perk. The one thing I would change is, once the "lobby" closed, I didn't know of any way of getting in touch with the hotel staff. There was no phone in the room or instructions on what to do when the staff leaves. I wasn't really sure where to get fresh towels. Once the front desk staff leaves, I felt we were kind of left to fend for ourselves. But overall, I would stay here again in the off-season. We really enjoyed our time.

Leisure Pet

4/10

Poor

13 Oct 2020

Verified traveler

Not worth the money or the hype

The Lake view is great BUT the service was horrible for the price we paid. I received a text at 1030 in the morning with my room number and key code stating the room was ready for us. When we arrived the door was open and the cleaning people were in the room so we went for lunch. When we came back to the hotel 2 hours later the cleaning staff was still cleaning our room and told us they were short staffed. We then went to reception who told us it is what it is and we can go to the bar to wait it out but when we got to the bar it wasn’t open. Reception did absolutely nothing to accommodate us for the inconvenience and another employee told us that the place is a big deal and gets celebrities all the time as if that is supposed to make up for the lack of service we received. Maybe if I was a celebrity I would’ve been treated better. I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

10 Oct 2020

Viviana

The service was amazing. Amanda made our stay extra special!

Business_and_leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

09 Oct 2020

Anup

The week in The Surf Lodge !!

nice and cozy property. Good for get together. Very quite and isolated.Super Stay !!

Partner

8/10

Excellent

17 Sep 2020

Verified traveler

nice room

My husband and I came to Montauk for a 1 night just to get away & booked the surf lodge. The room was very cute, nice big bathroom and we loved the hammock on the balcony. Would stay again.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

10 Sep 2020

The staff was wonderful during the pandemic. The place was very clean, but the room needed some repair. There was no cable service; only comcast, but our signal was weak and we kept losing the stream. Our room was right off the highway, so it was alittle noisey. The hotel and the shop is beautiful. There was a great event hosted on the deck.All and all we really enjoyed our stay.

10/10

Exceptional

02 Sep 2020

Verified traveler

beautiful lodge! enjoyed every bit. i loved the balcony view with the lake in the back! best part!!

8/10

Excellent

22 Aug 2020

Katelyn

Nice but...

The location was perfect and the room was very nice. However, the amenities were a bit lacking. The tv was not hooked up to any type of cable, and could not be paired with any of our devices (iPhones, iPads), so it was essentially useless. The hand soap, body wash, shampoo and conditioner were in the type of bottles that are just refilled after each guest checks out (frightening during these COVID times!) as opposed to being in small bottles that are just disposed of after use. Also, the pumps for both the hand soap and the body wash were broken and would not pump. There was no place to get ice for the room and for coolers. We were also told the restaurant is not currently operating which was not mentioned during booking. Other than those things, the stay was nice.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

13 Aug 2020

Verified traveler

Surf Lodge Getaway

Excellent hotel, super clean, nice, and cozy! Super helpful staff and a great, calm location for a romantic getaway. Great rooms as well.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Aug 2020

Verified traveler

Great!

This stay was great, hotel staff was more than accomodating and rooms were clean and safe.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

02 Aug 2020

erin

Small hotel feel

Despite the kitchen being closed the bar and lounge area are stunning for the few hotels guests. Its like a private oasis. Staff was exceptionally helpful during times of COVID.

Friends_and_family Friends

8/10

Excellent

01 Aug 2020

Jaclyn

stylish stay

Loved the room, beautifully furnished. Loved the hammock! The bathroom shower was great and with ogx products. Nice hang out area by the pond not crowded at all which I’m guessing in non covid times it can get crazy. Just the complimentary mini bar of items is only for weekend stays.

Friends_and_family Friends

2/10

Poor

21 Jul 2020

Verified traveler

I was checked in 2 hours late, the room was infested with bugs, no refund, one of the glass soap containers fell of the crooked shower shelf and broke glass all over the bathroom floor

Leisure