Kelley House

United States , Cape Cod - MA
EDGARTOWN, 23 Kelly Street
Show on Google | Map

100 reviews shown

10/10

Exceptional

16 Dec 2025

Holly

Very cozy comfortable hotel!!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

14 Dec 2025

Lutricia

We love it there! Fave hotel!

Business

10/10

Exceptional

08 Dec 2025

JEANNETTE

Very cute and quaint. Spectacular hostess and very accommodating

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

01 Dec 2025

Cristi

amazing stay

4/10

Poor

01 Dec 2025

Pierre-Yves

Nice staff but the property was overall severely understaffed which negatively impacted our stay unfortunately. The value for money wasn’t there.

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

30 Nov 2025

Nadia

Atmosphere and staff were accommodating.

I wish there was a bureau for clothing.

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

27 Nov 2025

Mohammed Tamim

Amazing!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

25 Nov 2025

Hiroshi

Overall excellence

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

24 Nov 2025

Chakie

Everything was perfect from start to finish. I could not recommend this property more.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

23 Nov 2025

Yuri

Clean room, well stocked, staff very attentive

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

11 Nov 2025

John

Friendly staff, clean room (housekeeping did an awesome job!), convenient parking, great location - walking distance to cafes, shops, restaurants, waterfront, etc, easy check-in/out.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Leisure Family

4/10

Poor

11 Nov 2025

Scott

The hotel is beautiful, but the staff couldn't care less. Perhaps it's post-season and they are burned out, but goodness.

Business

10/10

Exceptional

09 Nov 2025

Terry

The experience was top-notch. I've traveled to 45 countries and this hotel ranks with the best I've visited.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

07 Nov 2025

Desara

A beautiful stay at Faraway Martha’s Vineyard — stylish boutique vibe, spacious room, and a lovely pool view. Highly recommend

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

27 Oct 2025

Sharon Bueno

Off season, quiet and serene. Staff was friendly and helpful. Very nice vibe. Will definitely return :)

Partner

8/10

Excellent

22 Oct 2025

Michael

Nice place downtown. Room was very nice 3rd floor no elevator was weird. No breakfast.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

07 Oct 2025

Barry

Quick overnight, nice facility room better than adequate.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

07 Oct 2025

Lindsey

Great hotel beautiful interiors. The staff could be more welcoming and there is no lift so if you’re not on the ground floor good luck with cases. Great location and pool and outdoor bar area is lovely.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

02 Oct 2025

Stuart

Just a neat place to stay, very nice place.

10/10

Exceptional

02 Oct 2025

elizabeth

The staff was very friendly and helpful. Loved the pool and hot tub! It is located in the heart of Edgartown. Easy access to everything! Stayed here a few years ago before they renovated it. They did a great job! Will be back next year!

10/10

Exceptional

30 Sep 2025

Steven J.

Perfect

Perfect in every way. Beautiful decor, central location, smells wonderful

Partner

8/10

Excellent

29 Sep 2025

Gudrun Molly

Everything was wonderful except that it felt the hotel was understaffed.

Friends_and_family Friends

6/10

Pleasant

28 Sep 2025

Mark

Love going to Martha’s Vineyard and was looking forward to the stay at the Faraway, but unfortunately, it was quite disappointing. on the plus side the location and the overall vibe of the property was excellent. Unfortunately, the room which was over $800 a night was terribly noisy. We could hear the people above us walking around and doing whatever they were doing as if they were in the room themselves— as we could hear people going up and down the staircase that was nearby, which sounded like a herd of elephants to be honest. it’s an old building and so I get it, but these things are not acceptable at this caliber of a place Beyond that there were other things like the towels in the bathroom were really substandard quality. They weren’t plush at all, and frankly I’ve had equal if not even somewhat better towels and lesser hotels. The pool was not heated or so it didn’t seem —it was freezing cold, although there was a hot tub which was warm. Some people might not care about this, but I find it not satisfactory to not have a coffee maker in the room as well but honestly, if that was the only thing I would’ve given it a pass, but I did have to put a robe on and go out to the lobby to get coffee in the morning which again I don’t really feel is acceptable. unfortunately, I cannot recommend the Faraway.

10/10

Exceptional

26 Sep 2025

Amber

Great location, clean hotel, walkable to everything in edgartown

Leisure

8/10

Excellent

18 Sep 2025

Robert

Excellent resort but lacking on the service detail

Gorgeous interior, exterior, pool area, and location. Bathrooms weren’t super clean, front desk staff were not responsive and using personal phones. Pool bartender was awesome.

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

16 Sep 2025

Sandra

Great hotel in great location. Restaurants and shopping are right outside your door. We were lucky enough to get a water view from our room. I will definitely be staying there in the future.

Leisure

10/10

Exceptional

14 Sep 2025

Elham

Nice location!! the hotel is renewed snd we had a great stay!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

10 Sep 2025

Anne

Had a great time!

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

09 Sep 2025

ralph

Score of 7 mostly due to staff

We checked in, and the room was on the 3rd floor, no bell person to help with the bags, the staff was very cold and impersonal, and that feeling lingered for the next 3 days. When we asked about coffee, they said we had coffee service in the room, but we did not. When we mentioned this, they said they didn't know what their colleague from the night before had been talking about. We had an early fishing trip, and your shop opened later at 7. Our room was nice and comfortable (pillows were hard but otherwise ok), but the staff seemed more interested in talking to each other rather than guests; it was an odd feeling of us/them, whereas the facilities were warm and friendly, the staff were not (except the woman who managed the pool areas, she was very nice). Additionally, the Pelican Club was closed one night due to the weather, and I'm unsure why it was closed the other night.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

03 Sep 2025

Shazia

The property has a great location, very nice outdoor space and nice rooms. The lower rating was for two reasons. The first was our room was on the bottom floor, near the stairwell. Every morning starting at 6:30 all you could hear was banging doors and people going up and down these stairs. It was not sound proof AT ALL and you had no chance of sleeping. The second reason was the staff at the property mainly consisted of young people in their 20s. For a hotel of this price, you expect a level of service which they did not have. The person who checked us in was very rude to both us and someone else waiting. The staff outdoors by the pool were having their own day in the sun- they were very loud, socialized for hours on end which I wouldn’t care about but the noise was crazy, if we wanted spring break vibes we would have gone to Mexico. There were many people by the pool who moved to the opposite end to get away from their service station that they socialized around. People come here to relax and their attitude and noise was not it. At least wait until the guests are gone to take your Polaroids and scream about the party you’re excited about tonight.

Leisure Partner

6/10

Pleasant

01 Sep 2025

TAMMY

No elevator. Not enough towels 1 per person. Didn't replenish water. And staff was cold except 1 girl. Average room for the price

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

31 Aug 2025

Kathleen

The hotel was spectacular. The staff were helpful and friendly. The pool was beautiful.

Leisure Self

6/10

Pleasant

27 Aug 2025

Verified traveler

Awesome location, but not quite what we expected

This hotel was a pleasant surprise. Ideal location, spacious rooms, excellent amenities but the service was less than ideal. I tried consecutively to call the hotel on the morning of check in and never got a live body after trying maybe 5 times over the course of an hour. Understanding that it’s prime season, we understood. However, instances like this kept occurring. Late check out was accommodated for, but never put into the system so there was concern by staff that we were still in our room. All in all, we had a lovely stay but I certainly would not say that the hotel itself was a true Michelin key experience. The charm of Edgartown was all we needed.

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

21 Aug 2025

Jayme

Very well updated

Business Self

10/10

Exceptional

16 Aug 2025

Patrick

Wonderful staff!

Leisure Partner

6/10

Pleasant

09 Aug 2025

Georgianna

Beautifully decorated and nice workspace. Staff was not helpful with baggage at check-in. For the price, the toilet paper was cheap and no slippers. It was very nice that they allowed you to use the pool and property after the 11am checkout.

Business_and_leisure Self

8/10

Excellent

08 Aug 2025

Rich

Faraway

A fine hotel on Martha’s Vineyard. Very quaint, with modern amenities, and a laid back vibe.
Definitely on the pricey side.

Business

8/10

Excellent

07 Aug 2025

Jaimee

The property is beautiful and located in the heart of Edgartown's shopping area.

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

03 Aug 2025

Jessica

Our new favorite hotel!

The Faraway is our new favorite hotel! I have been coming to the Vineyard for over 25 years and our 4 day staycation at the hotel was the best weekend I have ever had on the island. The location can’t be beat. You are in the heart of Edgartown with everything being in walking distance. The amenities are great and the staff were spectacular. The best part is that the hotel is dog friendly too!

Friends_and_family Family

8/10

Excellent

02 Aug 2025

Gail

Coffee offered only in lobby was cold. Jacuzzi wasn’t heating and 8:00pm was too early to turn off fire pit.

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

24 Jul 2025

Natasha

Great location. Lobby is gorgeous, smelled great, sat by fireplace in the late evening. Pool area was relaxing, great drinks at bar and food served was tasty, 4 ft deep pool, also had a hot tub. Great low key vibes from the families with kids so was still able to relax. Clean rooms. Complimentary bikes. We had a room on first floor and could hear a lot of foot traffic overhead but quieted down during over night hours

8/10

Excellent

18 Jul 2025

Ruel

A gem

Lovely i enjoyed my stay inmensely.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

09 Jul 2025

Raymond

Great location, you can walk to shops, restaurants, harbor etc. New property with that charming old New England feel. Would definitely stay here again.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

03 Jul 2025

Devlin

A beautiful property with wonderful staff! The only hotel that I would stay in on the island.

Leisure Self

10/10

Exceptional

03 Jul 2025

Stephanny

Great location, clean, pet friendly, and wonderful staff

Leisure Pet

8/10

Excellent

30 Jun 2025

Michelle

A nice getaway

Overall very good. I did think it was unusual that upon check in we weren't told the typical: breakfast hours, gym location, wifi.... the staff all were in there 20s... so that was different. Pool area was nice and good service... overall we had a nice stay. Hope this feedback helps so that the welcome part is a bit more formal.

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

25 Jun 2025

Christopher J

10/10

Exceptional

25 Jun 2025

Virgina

Beautiful hotel with great outdoor restaurant! Highly recommend!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

23 Jun 2025

Kyle

Friendly staff

10/10

Exceptional

23 Jun 2025

Amanda

Loved the cleanliness,pool area, and prime location.

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

17 Jun 2025

Stacy

The hotel is impeccably designed and the rooms are spacious to accommodate family stays. The hotel staff did not seem knowledgeable about the hotel itself and were not able to answer basic questions readily; also, no one answers the phone number when calling the main line.

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

14 Jun 2025

Amy

Beautiful stay

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

13 Jun 2025

Lorraine

Faraway Martha’s Vineyard is easily in my top 3 hotels I’ve ever stayed at! The entire experience was nothing short of exceptional. The property is absolutely gorgeous every corner is thoughtfully designed, and the scent throughout the hotel is so inviting and refreshing. Everything was spotless, and the attention to detail really stood out.

The staff were warm, friendly, and made me feel truly welcome from the moment I arrived. From the cozy yet elegant decor to the little personal touches, you can tell a lot of care goes into making each guest’s stay special.

I wouldn’t consider staying anywhere else when I return to Martha’s Vineyard. This place is a true gem and worth every penny!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Jun 2025

Jamie

This property was a dream! The lobby smells amazing, the detail in design was beautiful, every inch of the hotel was spotless, byredo products in the bathrooms, free coffee and rose in the lobby, staff was attentive and so happy all the time. I was obsessed with my stay. Highly recommend!!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

11 Jun 2025

Susan

Beautiful property, well maintained, friendly and helpful staff. No elevator so request a room on the main floor if stairs are difficult.

8/10

Excellent

11 Jun 2025

Bledar

Nice loatio

10/10

Exceptional

09 Jun 2025

Stephanie

Amazing! Perfect getaway for family

Friends_and_family Family

4/10

Poor

07 Jun 2025

Jennie

Room smelled moldy and was very damp. Ceiling was so low it felt like being in a basement. Could touch ceiling with palm of my hand and it was actually coming undone in one spot, was buckling. Realized before booking it was an older building but the noise level was awful. Ground floor is not appropriate for guests in my opinion and not worth the +$629 price. No amenities kit, no simple items like shower caps. No DND for door. Cleaning team left supplies in our room. Staff wasn't trained or on boarded. Didn't know menu items. Coffee bar in morning had cold coffee and never replenished unless you asked. Just messy and not a well run establishment. It's more of an influencer type spot for photo oops of the lobby and beyond that it's shabby chic at best.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

07 Jun 2025

Harriet

This property was outstanding. Beautiful and loved our stay. Only things would have liked is our bed to be made and coffee in the room. Other than that cannot fault it and Thank you for having us

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

06 Jun 2025

Alicia

Beautiful grounds and very friendly staff. Enjoyed using the bikes to tour around.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

05 Jun 2025

Madeline

Loved the renovations, beautiful hotel

Leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

02 Jun 2025

Frances

fyi no elevator

Business_and_leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

30 May 2025

Charles

The Hotel is absolutely gorgeous and clean...the staff goes out of there way to help in any way they can. We were upgraded and appreciated all the staff that went about and beyond to make my week of my Fiances Birthday as well as helping me as I lost my mom a few months ago and was able to relax and enjoy some down time. I HOPE TO BE BACK SOMESAY !

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

28 May 2025

ERIKA

Excellent location and beautiful hotel! The property was impeccable and provided a truly relaxing atmosphere. Most importantly, the front desk team and staff were very hospitable and accommodating.

Great place to stay while visiting Martha’s Vineyard.

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

28 May 2025

Bastiou

What a gem! So glad I picked this place for our memorable stay in Martha’s Vineyard!

10/10

Exceptional

23 May 2025

Gabriel

Great staff

10/10

Exceptional

20 May 2025

Susan

Perfect location for accessing everything. Attentive staff. Great accommodations. I would highly recommend!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

15 May 2025

Darryl

Our room was perfect. Fantastic furnishings. The property landscaping is flawless. The staff was extremely helpful. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone going to Edgartown.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 May 2025

Anemona

Beautiful new property with a gorgeous view and pool

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

12 May 2025

Cristina

great location great property

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

11 May 2025

Shalanah

Nice location, friendly staff and clean rooms.

Leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

09 May 2025

Jennifer

Wonderful, beautiful, great location, friendly staff!

8/10

Excellent

05 May 2025

Tabitha

Beauti

10/10

Exceptional

30 Apr 2025

Fergus

Very Nice Property

10/10

Exceptional

08 Dec 2024

Patricia

Beautiful place! Amazing staff

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

01 Dec 2024

Nadia

Everything was great! Just wish there was a bureau for clothing. Bed side table drawer was not enoufh space!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

29 Nov 2024

Herbert

Wonderful

10/10

Exceptional

27 Nov 2024

Marc

Staff was incredible

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

16 Nov 2024

Gerald

Lovely hotel and location.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

31 Oct 2024

Holly

We loved the cool records and record players in each room. We loved our balcony overlooking the pool areas and water.
To wake up and see the sunrise over all the sail boats was perfection!
The fire pit was nice to sit around to on our fist night!
And the staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

29 Oct 2024

Eric

Great experience - highly recommend

10/10

Exceptional

28 Oct 2024

Megan

A must-stay in Edgartown!

The Faraway is absolutely delightful. The rooms are beautifully decorated and from the second you walk in, the signature scent is relaxing and comforting. The pool and fire pit are beautiful and the perfect place to spend a few hours. We loved the location—just a few steps from shopping, dining, and the water. A must-stay in Edgartown!

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

26 Oct 2024

stacey

Even the air smells different when staying at Faraway

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

25 Oct 2024

Roberta

We had an excellent stay. We had 3 rooms. Our 5 year old nephew was thrilled that the pool was open and part of it heated and he was swimming in the middle of October.

Leisure

10/10

Exceptional

24 Oct 2024

Sherrie

Proper is so pretty and exceptionally clean.

Leisure Partner

8/10

Excellent

22 Oct 2024

Patricia

Modern and nice. BUT they blow a very heavy scent throughout hotel and grounds that is over powering. Had to use towel at room for jam to keep smell out. Over powering. Throat and sinuses were bothered. If you have asthma or scent bother your throat don’t stay here. You may need your inhaler. It’s too bad but just could not sit around lobby.

Leisure

10/10

Exceptional

21 Oct 2024

Vinyard

it was great

10/10

Exceptional

20 Oct 2024

Joanne

Excellent experience!

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

19 Oct 2024

Richard

Great location! Was in the center of town. Restaurants and shops were all within walking distance.

10/10

Exceptional

18 Oct 2024

Joanne

Everything was perfect apart from street noise that wasn’t any fault of the hotel
We’ll be back

Business_and_leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

17 Oct 2024

Michelle

Amazing vibe, beautiful property, super comfortable rooms/bed and always got excellent recommendations from the staff. Amazingly refurbished property - we thoroughly enjoyed our time there. Our only caveat is that the rooms are not well soundproofed - conversations are easily heard in conjunctive rooms, outside, etc.

8/10

Excellent

17 Oct 2024

Cynthia

This hotel is in the most convenient location to everything Edgartown. Everyone we met on the staff were kind and helpful. The Provided bathrobes were lovely

We were a bit disappointed In the lack of dresser space. Only one small drawer in the night table. We were also a bit disappointed that there was no heat in the hotel. It was not turned on. On our last day, when we returned from being out all day, our room keys did not work. The staff was Incredibly helpful trying to get this fixed. After changing the battery failed, we were given a master key, which worked. However because of the key issue, we did not receive any housekeeping services that day.

Although The hotel does provide coffee in the morning, we would have appreciated it being offered later in the afternoon when we returned after being out all day.

Leisure

10/10

Exceptional

12 Oct 2024

Brian

Melissa was kind, courteous, and helpful
An ssset to your property

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

02 Oct 2024

Paul

Great property, however, no elevators so if you have trouble with stairs, ask for the first floor. Also, the doors on the main building do not have locks on them. After I complained about the security of guests with open doors, the front desk girl acted indifferent and told me other guests have complained too. When I said why don’t you tell the manager, she shrugged. A real dummy. I told her I was going to put something on social media and it didn’t seem to faze her. I hope the Faraway management is reading this and will take action. It’s not that hard guys to put locks on doors.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

01 Oct 2024

Susan

Amazing !!! So beautiful, and “ smelt” great !

Friends

8/10

Excellent

22 Sep 2024

Mike

Great place.

10/10

Exceptional

15 Sep 2024

Jon

If I could rank Faraway 100 stars I would. The most PERFECT getaway for my wife and I on our annual anniversary trip to the vineyard. We will not be staying anywhere but Faraway in the future. We are HOOKED!

6/10

Pleasant

12 Sep 2024

Paul

Parking advertised as available but in reality very limited to first come, first served, only about 10 spaces are on premises while additional, still small spot, is located couple of street away. Hotel is recently renovated so everything is in very good shape, outside and pool area are very nice but inside not so (I was in main building) Whoever did interior design should be fired, random pieces of decorations, orange and brown motive, strange green paint in hallway. My room (king) was large comparing to others at 320 sq ft but for some strange reason had window AC while others had not. Advertised with full size fridge, in reality it is just micro one, no coffee maker. Site proudly display turntables in every room, interesting addition if only works, ours was not. Safe in the room was locked open, unable to use. Staff is nice and helpful, they offered to address the issues but shouldn't it be all ready upon my arrival? Speaking about arrival, when I was filling pre-arrival form, I stated desire to check in early. Not only I was unable to check in early but not even on time at advertised 4pm, our room was not ready until 4:30. Manager was apologetic, offered explanation and compensation but I would prefer to avoid sitting in the lobby for long time. Overall, Faraway is one of the better options in Edgartown but not the best.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Sep 2024

Pamela

The Faraway exceeded my expectations !Checking in I was greeted by Melissa, who was friendly and accommodating.
The pool is well maintained, love the music and vibe. Food and service were superb. Staff, very helpful!

Leisure Self

10/10

Exceptional

10 Sep 2024

Violetta

Stunning property and great service. A special place in Edgartown

Leisure Family