La Collegiata

8/10

Excellent

06 Oct 2025

David

Very helpful staff

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

24 Aug 2025

Stephanie

We had to book this hotel last minute due to issues with our villa. The staff were excellent and could not be more helpful, it was lovely to speak to them and also learn a bit more about the history of the building. They were aware of our situation and ready to help further if needed.
The hotel itself is absolutely stunning and the breakfast (food, setting, service) was top notch. If you have the opportunity to stay here - definitely go for it!

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

03 Aug 2025

Rachel

Pure sanctuary for Tuscan relaxation with the most beautiful views. Everything about this place is wonderful, from the moment we arrived we felt relaxed and well looked after.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

02 Jul 2025

Scott

A very beautiful property with amazing views. The staff was extremely hospitable and made us feel very much at home.

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

26 Jun 2025

Louise

A very beautiful property and grounds. Pool area lovely. Limited food options and no prices on the drinks. Felt the staff could have been a bit more friendly and welcoming. We arrived slightly early and were told we could not use the facilities until our room has been assigned. Never had that before. Not terribly helpful on a hot day.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

16 Jun 2025

Alia

Beautiful property and friendly staff. We stayed here for 6 nights with our 3 month old. The staff is very accommodating and friendly. Breakfast was great but the same options for 6 days got a little boring after some time. Also for food after hours you have to drive to town. One suggestion I would make is to add a coffee or tea maker in the room. It was advertised as the rooms have one but they don’t. A lot of early mornings I would have loved to enjoy some coffee/espresso on my balcony but did not have the option. And the Restaurant doesn’t open till 8am. Overall still great stay.

Leisure Family_with_children

10/10

Exceptional

16 Jun 2025

Rosalina

It was a memorable stay! The resort is quiet, clean, cozy and royal and historical. It was a monastery 500 years ago. The view from the gardens is stunning! The staff is very nice, friendly and professional! I would definitely go back in the future!

10/10

Exceptional

05 Nov 2024

Al

Wonderful. Beautiful. Historical. Great, great staff!

Friends_and_family Family

10/10

Exceptional

08 Oct 2024

Allan

A beautiful setting within a beautiful city. We loved this place overall. Staff were very friendly, everything about the hotel was top notch...except the comfort of the bed for me. That was the only slight negative. We would love to visit again though. Basically outstanding.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

08 Oct 2024

Andrea

Stunning property and incredible staff. Our favorite stay on our vacation!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

16 Jun 2024

Valery

Most amazing property I have ever been. Old And modern together. Very comfortable .
most accommodating staff .
it’s not just the property. It’s an Unusual experience.

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

05 Jun 2024

Marco

Amazing property!! Less than a 10 minute drive to san gimignano parking.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

04 Jun 2024

Verified traveler

Tuscan Treasure

The perfect Tuscany experience with historical significance, beauty, and comfort.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Sep 2023

Negin

Beautiful views of San Gimignano from the outdoor bar and breakfast area. Our room was large, and clean. Staff is friendly and helpful. Gave us great restaurant and wine tasting ideas.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

22 Aug 2023

Michael

Property is highly recommended. We were very pleased as it provided a real country Tuscany feel about it. Very well appointed and 'historical'. Staying facing the garden in the summer had a drawback of mosquitos getting into the room. Hotel did not seem to relate this problem, not offer any solutions, so that was just a bit disappointing. Otherwise, this is highly recommended.

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

06 Jul 2023

Jonathan

The grounds are amazing and the view out front to the Tuscan Hills will make you forget all of your worries. Clean room, great bathrooms. The place has that old century feel while still feeling modern enough. Make sure you pay before through Expedia or check out and not leave like other hotels in the US, I got an angry call from the front desk woman who’s thought I wasn’t paying and threatened to call the police even though there was a card on file that was used to hold the room. Besides that one interaction which I didn’t love everything else was amazing.

Leisure Self

10/10

Exceptional

05 Oct 2019

Roberto

Excelente option

Amazing place, service really good and excellent location

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

21 Sep 2019

Verified traveler

What a unique and beautiful place to stay - everything from the room to the overall hotel and gardens were delightful. An absolute stand out though, were the staff - they were so happy, welcoming and helpful. They outshone the beauty of the physical hotel. Thank you for making a stay so memorable.

Business_and_leisure Partner

8/10

Excellent

14 Sep 2019

Verified traveler

La Collegieta

The views from the hotel were very nice
The morning staff were very friendly

We booked a Suite and our friends booked a normal room, both rooms are exactly the same not worth booking a suite
Late night staff were very rude we had a gecko in our room, we were told to leave the hotel if we can’t sleep with a gecko inside the room until we requested our money back

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

03 Sep 2019

Verified traveler

The place looks incredible, it is incredible but the staff make the place unique.

Leisure Partner

6/10

Pleasant

30 Aug 2019

N/A

Beautiful grounds and exterior of the property, but the interior was very tired, service was definitely lacking relative to the other hotels we stayed in Tuscany and there was almost a “stale” vibe there (i.e. it was weirdly quiet and dimly lite). We booked the nice room with the jacuzzi at the top but we couldn’t get in the jacuzzi as i) first you had to request them to fill the tub 1 hour prior (you’d think they’d fill it automatically when you get in) and ii) once it was filled, we tried to get in but the temperature was so hot you could almost boil a lobster... we waited for 2 hours to see if it cooled down but to no avail. As this was one of the most expensive places we stayed in Tuscany, while it does have remedying qualities, it was honestly a let down relative to the other hotels (particularly considering this was the most expensive).

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

30 Aug 2019

Mark

Beautiful Tuscany

Tuscany at its best
Absolutely perfect in every way

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

28 Aug 2019

Kevin

Location Plus.

Location ++. We have seen some negative reviews about this place but our experience was superb with a very helpful team onsite. The view from the grounds is fantastic and chilling by the pool on a hot Tuscan day was wonderful. This is a converted monetary so people expecting a modern plush room should consider something else - but you will be missing out on something truly beautiful. The service was excellent.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

07 Jul 2019

Verified traveler

An amazing property in a handy location if you have a car. Just a short 5 minute drive in to the n town. The pool was a bonus in the heat. The only negative was a preset air conditioner in the room which was set too high. We sweltered when in the room and despite asking for it to be adjusted a number of times nothing was done

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

02 Jul 2019

Verified traveler

La ubicación que permite una vista soberbia de San Gimignano

Leisure

10/10

Exceptional

28 Jun 2019

Verified traveler

Fantastic location with stunning views to San Gimignano.great pool to cool off in after hot day of sightseeing

Leisure Friends

10/10

Exceptional

28 Jun 2019

Alonso

We shall return! it's a destination

The property is perfect with an amazing view, the food outstanding and the people very professional and nice. We will come back

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

23 Jun 2019

Verified traveler

Sitting outside with a wonderful dinner, looking out on the vista at San Gimignano......breathtaking!!!!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

27 May 2019

Verified traveler

The property was private and beautiful and the chef was wonderful. We had a fabulous meal and the service was friendly and efficient. We enjoyed our stay and would recommend this hotel to anyone who wants to get away from the crowds. The views were great also.

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

26 May 2019

Reginald

Beautiful property. Friendly staff. Great location.

Leisure Family

8/10

Excellent

22 Sep 2018

Verified traveler

Close to San Gimignano, good facilties and friendly staff

8/10

Excellent

17 Sep 2018

Verified traveler

The property was very nicely manicured and the beds were very soft and comfortable.

There should have been more staff on duty for the size of the property, however.

10/10

Exceptional

12 Sep 2018

C

Great hotel near to the beautiful San Gimigiano

A very nice hotel, which has been very well restored from an old monastery. We had a lovely large room, with air conditioning, a very comfy bed, and a lovely bathroom. Although out of the centre of San Gimigiano, it is within walking distance of the town (20 mins), and we walked in almost every day during our stay.
All of the staff were very friendly and professional.
The breakfast is very good with an excellent selection of breads, cakes, fruit, cereals, yoghurts, meats, cheeses, jams, etc, and you can also have freshly made omlettes/eggs of your choice.
We ate in the hotel restaurant one evening, and the food and service was very good.
The pool area is very relaxing.

10/10

Exceptional

10 Sep 2018

Verified traveler

Beautiful grounds, lovely room, great pool.

Only slight negative was the food was quite expensive and fairly average.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

14 Aug 2018

Verified traveler

Beautiful location, unhelpful rude staff.

The location with a view over the town was lovely and so was the pool area. Unfortunately the service was not good and the hotel smelt musty. The reception staff were abrupt and management were rude and unaccommodating. Upon check-in we said that we had some Italian friends (a couple, no kids) in the area and we booked lunch for 4 at the terrace restaurant for 2 days later. The next day a manager told us that the restaurant would not be open but that our friends could join us by the pool and have a light lunch there, but that they could not swim in the pool as they were not insured. We said OK. We went out for lunch instead with our friends and then all came back to the pool, with the intention of spending an hour relaxing before they had to drive home. As soon as we had ordered drinks a staff member came out to us and said our friends were not allowed to be by the pool at all and they had to leave. This was incredibly embarrassing. If the hotel had said this policy in the beginning we would not have brought our friends in, but we did the right thing and asked in advance. To have the hotel tell us OK and and then have our friends turfed out (they were not even allowed to finish their drinks) was appalling. We were not noisy and they had been there only 10 minutes before they were asked to leave. We felt lied to and let down and were very unhappy about it. Do not offer one thing then take it back, especially not loudly in public and in front of our guests!

Partner

8/10

Excellent

14 Aug 2018

Em

Great place to relax. Only thing missing is coffe on the lobby. Breakfast is open at 8 am. We are usually up at 6 am and there is no way to get coffe before then. I wich that had free coffe in the lobby fir the early birds.

10/10

Exceptional

17 Jul 2018

Louise

Breathtaking! This hotel is beautiful. If you want a romantic hotel in this stunning town, this is the place for you

10/10

Exceptional

15 Jul 2018

kb

Gem of a hotel with amazing views

Fantastic hotel with beautiful pool and sunbathing area. Staff very helpful and polite. Room was a good size, with good air con. Would definitely recommend as a base for exploring the surrounding area.

10/10

Exceptional

11 Jul 2018

Brendan

Beautiful hotel with stunning views

Great location looking towards San Gimignano. Lovely staff, very good restaurant and for relaxing by the pool.

10/10

Exceptional

20 May 2018

Pamela

Exceeded our expectations in all ways
Also a great location to explore Tuscany

Partner

4/10

Poor

11 Jul 2017

DR TIMOTHY WARD

Simply dreadful service

Beautiful location, ruined by indifferent, rude and aggressive staff. when we arrived. we asked for an early breakfast (7 AM) on our departure day. We were told it was impossible to have any food before 8 AM (4* hotel, really?) and if we were leaving early we should settle our bill the night before. Charming welcome! Later we were enjoying a quiet drink in the lounge when a receptionist walked in and without acknowledging us switched on a huge TV to a blaring football channel. The bar was unstaffed and we had to wander around looking for someone to serve. The same receptionist dismissively waved us away, Stating 'go to the garden, Someone will serve you'. The hotel was taken over by a wedding to whom the staff devoted all the attention. They removed breakfast tables as guests left, to set up for the wedding. We were banish to the pool for lunch as the wedding party took over all the eating area. At dinner we were sat at an outside table 5m from the wedding party and live band. When we told the waiter we have decided to go into town to dinner he angrily cleared our table whilst we sat at it. At midnight, When the loud wedding disco music was still blaring, we rang to ask when it would finish. The receptionist shouted down the phone 'Will finish soon, what's your problem?' Simply dreadful. And we can't complain to the hotel as reception staff twice told us they didn't know who the manager was or who ran the hotel. It beggars belief.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

26 Jun 2017

lucas

Tuscan hideaway

Great location, quiet hideaway on the edge of San Gimignano. Converted 15th century convent, beautiful architecture and grounds. Staff extremely accomodating. Superb breakfasts, the one dinner we had less so but short cab ride to town for many options.

10/10

Exceptional

09 Jun 2017

Mike

La Collegiata, San Gimignano

A charming monastery built in 1587. This 20 rooms, one suite ,restaurant, , large pool, and gorgeous grounds is a must to visit. We stayed 4 days and it was not enough time to see and do everything.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

14 May 2017

CCW

A Peaceful Location

With a beautiful view, a fragrant garden, singing birds, tall pines, it was a true vacation setting. The service was refined, food delicious. A touch of elegance

8/10

Excellent

11 Sep 2016

Val

Great place to relax\n

Lovely peaceful hotel in beautiful surroundings, ideal for a get away from it all break

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

30 Jul 2016

Verified traveler

Bad staff

We asked for extra pillows and sheets and the hotel charged us for 30 Euro for that. The hotel staff attitude was very bad and didn't behave nice to us. The hotel structure and overall view is amazing but definetly would not come back with this kind of service.

10/10

Exceptional

19 Jul 2016

Nigel

A Real Gem

This hotel ticked all the boxes for us. Wonderful setting only 5 mins drive to San Gimignano. Set in an old 16th Century nunnery. Absolutely loved the place. Only stayed two nights but wished it had been two weeks. Will definitely return.

10/10

Exceptional

15 Jul 2016

Damon

Small Cozy hotel w/ Great View & Excellent Service

Unexpected treasure. 20 minute walk from San Gimignano. Service is 1st class. Had to move rooms because of a last minute change and hotel staff stored and moved luggage and drove car and loaded luggage from room. Staff gave great recommendations on wineries.

8/10

Excellent

20 Jun 2016

Verified traveler

Avoid the restaurant at all cost.

The hotel and setting are beautiful, but our stay was ruined by an inedible meal and the rude behavior of the hotel staff. Our filet was a miserable cut of meat, and quite possibly not beef. When we complained we were met with rude responses and told that we were wrong about the quality of the cut of meat. Enjoy the hotel, but don't eat at the on-site restaurant.

Partner

6/10

Pleasant

21 Oct 2015

Verified traveler

Mixed.

The air condition was turned off for the season so we had the windows open. Then it was quite noisey with the kitchen below the room....definitely ask for a room that is not above the kitchen. The restaurant was \"fancy\" but the food was just \"OK\" for the price paid. The dessert was horrible.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Oct 2015

Kimberly

Beauty and serenity in Tuscany

We loved La Collegiate! This former convent is lovely and peaceful. The buildings and grounds (gardens, pool, patios) are beautiful and beautifully maintained. There's even a small open chapel with a fresco of St Francis of Assisi in it. The decor is the right blend of antique furnishings and modern comforts. Our room and bath were spacious. The views from our room stunning. Breakfast was amazing - with a broad array of fruits, yogurts, eggs (even scrambled), meats, cereals, breads and juices. Finally, the staff was warm and helpful while not being intrusive. It really felt a bit like being in a convent. Lovely and peaceful. The hotel is several km from San Gimignano, but the town is easy to get to and parking was plentiful (in October). It also became our base for exploring other towns in Tuscany.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

09 Oct 2015

shaun

The stay at la collegiata was everything we wanted , location, beautiful accommodation, very friendly and helpful staff.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

16 Sep 2015

Wei

Beautiful hotel

Beautiful building and the surrounding area. View is to just amazing. Nice size room and the bathroom (annex 24), very clean, good power show. Breakfast is nice. Lot of choices, delicious pin nuts cake, it's the best we've had in Tuscany.Friendly staff. Nice 15-20 minutes walk to the town. Very quiet day and night. We would definitely stay again.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

12 Aug 2015

Yolanda

Little Oasis

Very nice place to stay and chill out, would stay again.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

27 Jul 2015

Richard

Gorgeous hotel, staff, and food!!

The hotel is gorgeous and we have no complaints about the cleanliness, the staff, or the food (restaurant is superb). The only reason we didn't rate it 5 stars all the way is that the air conditioning is not very strong and we didn't sleep well the first night due to the high temp in the room. We asked the staff to leave the AC on during turn down service the next few days and it did cool down after tentative.

Partner

8/10

Excellent

21 Jul 2015

Andrew

Great option for San Gimignano

Lovely hotel, very nice pool area. Friendly staff

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

17 Jul 2015

Maria

Awesome!

This is a beautiful property with impeccable rooms and very helpful staff. La Collegiata exceeded my expectations!!!!

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

14 Jul 2015

iwona&daniel

Very good choice

Great hotel with very nice staff
Good for one night just to visit San Girmignano or for a week to travel across Tuscany and back for night

6/10

Pleasant

25 May 2015

Verified traveler

Get a deal - or its not worth it.

For the price we paid - there was a little bit of disappointment. this is a very high end establishment, and the cost reflects that. Thus I would assume that doors would close and positively lock without looking like I could lean on them and they would open... or that the air conditioning would work - even after the hotel staff said that they fixed it.

All in all no a bad hotel - just did not live up to the price.

Family

10/10

Exceptional

05 May 2015

Chris

Great property! A San Gimignano gem.

Great hotel! We stayed in the former chapel of the building. Even though the room did not have very big windows, it was very spacious, comfortable and quiet. The hotel staff was excellent and helped arrange a highly enjoyable wine tasting at a local winery. The building and property are beautiful. Located only a few kilometers from San Gimignano, I highly recommend this hotel.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

17 Oct 2014

brian

San Gimignano luxury

Excellent hotel. Warm welcome, comfortable room in beautiful surroundings. Having read previous reviews we wanted to sample the hotel restaurant and we weren't disappointed. The food and service were of the highest standard.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

19 Sep 2014

Matt

Tuscan Heaven

This hotel was amazing! Perfect romantic setting in the most picturesque Tuscan town. The staff was extremely helpful and friendly, and spoke terrific English. The rooms were spacious and the beds were very comfortable. Simple but well-decorated. The grounds are beautiful, and the surrounding scenery is amazing. Daily breakfast had huge variety of delicious hot and cold foods and a great view of San Gimignano. You will need a rental car to stay here and take advantage of the surrounding wineries and fantastic restaurants. Getting around was easy. The hotel offers tours, but we were able to do it all ourselves with a rental car, including visits to Sienna and Florence. We have visited many beautiful countries, but this was one of the most beautiful, picturesque hotels that we have ever stayed at.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

06 Aug 2014

frank

Fantastic! Heaven on Earth

Great experience every bit of the hotel was fantastic. The breakfast in the morning is exceptional. The views to San Giminano were amazing!

10/10

Exceptional

15 Jul 2013

Verified traveler

amazing service

We had a too short stay at La Collegiata. The facility is beautiful and it is very conveniently located for visiting San Gimingnano, but the tremendous service is what stood out. We had problems with returning a rental car to Firenze and the staff were all over it. They are amongst the best hotel staff I have ever encountered.

10/10

Exceptional

22 Sep 2025

vanni

La Collegiata è una bellissima location,,vicinissima a San Gimignano ,inserita in un parco molto bello e ben curato arricchito da una bella piscina.Vista su San Gimignano spettacolare.La nostra camera e la colazione adeguate al prezzo

Leisure Partner

2/10

Poor

07 Jul 2025

Martin

Un lieu enchanteur, terni par un manque de discernement

Je voyage seul et suis arrivé tard à l’hôtel, vers 18h. L’endroit est tout simplement sublime : les jardins, l’architecture, la vue… un véritable rêve toscan. En arrivant, le premier mot que j’ai prononcé à la réception, avant même de dire bonjour, a été « Wow ».

Il faisait près de 40 degrés. Comme je fais un long road trip de trois semaines, j’avais choisi cet hôtel en partie pour sa piscine. Mon rythme est simple : repos l’après-midi, découverte des villages en soirée. J’ai donc demandé, très poliment, s’il était possible de payer pour un départ tardif afin de profiter un peu de la piscine le lendemain. La réponse fut un non catégorique. J’ai alors proposé, toujours aussi gentiment, de simplement pouvoir rester quelques heures au bord de la piscine, en offrant bien sûr de payer ce service. Nouveau refus net.

Le lendemain matin, plusieurs chaises longues étaient inoccupées. Je comprends qu’il y ait des règles, mais un peu de jugement aurait suffi. Ce manque total de souplesse m’a laissé un goût amer. Quand la réceptionniste m’a accompagnée à la chambre, elle m’a dit : « Pour toute demande, n’hésitez pas à appeler la réception. » Phrase sans doute apprise par cœur… dommage qu’aucune des deux premières demandes n’ait été accueillie avec ouverture.

Un cadre magnifique, mais une hospitalité rigide. Je ne me suis pas senti le bienvenu.

Leisure Self

8/10

Excellent

06 Jul 2025

CHRISTOPHE

bien

Leisure Family

10/10

Exceptional

14 Aug 2024

Igor

Perfect

10/10

Exceptional

29 Aug 2023

elizabe

Instalaciones hermosas, unicacion perfecta y personal muy amable

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

05 Sep 2021

Giuseppe A.

Hotel con ottimo rapporto qualita' prezzo

Siamo stati alla Collegiata due notti per visitare San Gimignano e ci siamo trovati benissimo.La struttura e' antica e molto bella,i saloni sono decorati con camini d'epoca e alcuni quadri di squisita fattura.
La stanza era piacevole ,con le dotazioni essenziali.
Molto bella la sala ristorante e il terrazzino dove cenare all'aperto con vista sulle torri.
Per quanto riguarda la piscina e' bella ed immersa in un bel giardino,anche se i lettini risultano un po datati.
Buona la colazione

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

26 Aug 2021

Patrizia

Una vacanza in una favola

Struttura favolosa ben curata. Personale disponibile e gentile

Partner

8/10

Excellent

13 Aug 2021

Verified traveler

Flot hotel og værelse! Fin beliggenhed og lækker pool. Maden også god. Sengen var dog for kort i længden og vi døjede med myrer på værelset blot vi havde lidt mad. Stemningen er dog for højtidelig og der mangler hygge.

Partner

10/10

Exceptional

11 Jul 2021

Paul C

La Vita e bella

Unglaublich tolles Hotel… Mit unglaublichen Blick… Und super Frühstück. Gerne jederzeit wieder

Friends_and_family Friends

10/10

Exceptional

12 Aug 2020

Loris

Simpatia e professionalità, ottimi servizi e strutture. Grazie!

Leisure Partner

10/10

Exceptional

25 Aug 2019

Verified traveler

Wonderful stay with most friendly staff, relaxed and almost familiar atmosphere, perfect to head out exploring Tuscany bur coming home to what felt like a little hidden treasure. Fun fact: talked to some local restaurant owners in San Gimignano and they also said that La Collegiata is the best place to stay

Leisure Friends