RO
Room Only
Accommodation only. Meals are usually not included.
Show prices in
Choose a currency for your trip.
Popular currencies
More currencies
More crypto
No currencies found. Try a name or currency code.
9.4/10Excellent1,151 Reviews
Cleanliness9.6/10 9.6
Service9.6/10 9.6
Comfort9.6/10 9.6
Condition9.4/10 9.4
Amenities9.2/10 9.2
See all ratings- Business hotels
- Hotels with spa
- Family hotels
Room prices, availability, meal plans and cancellation terms are confirmed for your selected dates.
About The Garden City Hotel
Pamper yourself with a visit to the spa, which offers massages, body treatments, and facials. You're sure to appreciate the recreational amenities, including an indoor pool, a 24-hour fitness center, and bicycles to rent. This hotel also features complimentary wireless internet access, concierge services, and babysitting (surcharge).
Enjoy American cuisine at Red Salt Room, one of the hotel's 2 restaurants, or stay in and take advantage of the room service (during limited hours). Snacks are also available at the coffee shop/cafe. Relax with a refreshing drink at one of the 2 bars/lounges.
Buffet breakfasts are served on weekdays from 7:00 AM to 11:00 AM and on weekends from 7:30 AM to 10:30 AM for a fee. Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, express check-out, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Planning an event in Garden City?
This hotel has 25000 square feet (2323 square meters) of space consisting of conference space and meeting rooms.
Show less
A stay at The Garden City Hotel places you in the heart of Garden City, within a 10-minute drive of Roosevelt Field Mall and Old Westbury Gardens. This family-friendly hotel is 6 mi (9.7 km) from UBS Arena and 6.1 mi (9.8 km) from Belmont Park.
Stay in one of 269 guestrooms featuring flat-screen televisions. Your room comes with a pillowtop bed. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms feature showers, designer toiletries, and hair dryers.
Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, express check-out, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Planning an event in Garden City? This hotel has 25000 square feet (2323 square meters) of space consisting of conference space and meeting rooms. Free valet parking is available onsite.
Popular amenities
Swimming Pool
Free WiFi
Parking available
Dining services
Pet friendly
Concierge
Laundry
Spa
Gym
Entertainment
Non-smoking
Childcare
Business facilities
Banquet facilities
Accessible facilities
Check-in and check-out
Check-in from
4:00 PM
Check-in until
4:00 AM
Check-out until
11:00 AM
Minimum check-in age
21
Hotel policies
Beach nearby
Noise-free rooms not guaranteed
Guests will receive an email with special check-in instructions
Guest will receive an email before arrival 24 hours
Professional property host/manager
Property does not offer onsite COVID-19 testing
Property does not require health documentation at check-in
Pets allowed
Pet max weight (per pet) in kg is 23
Pet max weight (per pet) in lb is 50
Only dogs are allowed
Maximum number of pets per room 1
Service animals are allowed
Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions
Cleaning and safety
Sanitization
Contactless check-out is available
Cashless transactions are available
Essential Travel
Essential workers only - NO
Important information
-
Property Alerts
You'll be asked to pay the following charges at the property. Fees may include applicable taxes:
- Resort fee: USD 43.45 per accommodation, per night
We have included all charges provided to us by the property.
-
You need to know
- Pool access available from 9:00 AM to 7:00 PM.
- Reservations are required for massage services and spa treatments. Reservations can be made by contacting the hotel prior to arrival, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.
- Children 12 years old and younger stay free when occupying the parent or guardian's room, using existing bedding.
- The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.
- The property allows pets in specific rooms only and has other pet restrictions (surcharges apply and can be found in the Fees section). Guests can arrange to bring pets by contacting the property directly, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.
- Cashless payment methods are available for all transactions.
- Contactless check-out is available.
-
Special Instructions
This property doesn't offer after-hours check-in. Guests will receive an email within 24 hours before arrival with check-in instructions. Front desk staff will greet guests on arrival at the property. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
-
Instructions
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards, debit cards, and cash
- Cashless transactions are available
- Noise-free guestrooms cannot be guaranteed
- Safety features at this property include a carbon monoxide detector, a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, a security system, a first aid kit, and window guards
- Please note that cultural norms and guest policies may differ by country and by property; the policies listed are provided by the property
-
Minimal age
21
-
Optional fees
- Fee for buffet breakfast: approximately USD 40.00 to 60.00 per person
- Pet fee: USD 75 per pet, per day
- Service animals are exempt from fees
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
-
Spoken Language
Hindi
Korean
English
Croatian
Chinese (Mandarin)
Spanish
Serbian
Nearby attractions
Cathedral of the Incarnation
0.4 km / 0.3 mi
Garden City Historical Society Museum
1.1 km / 0.7 mi
Adelphi University
1.4 km / 0.9 mi
NYU Winthrop Hospital
2.8 km / 1.8 mi
Roosevelt Field Mall
3.5 km / 2.1 mi
Hofstra University
3.9 km / 2.4 mi
Nassau Community College
4.1 km / 2.6 mi
Long Island Children's Museum
4.5 km / 2.8 mi
Mercy Medical Center
4.6 km / 2.9 mi
Nassau County Firefighters Museum and Education Center
4.8 km / 3 mi
Cradle of Aviation Museum
4.8 km / 3 mi
Hempstead Lake State Park
3.8 km / 2.3 mi
Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum
5.8 km / 3.6 mi
Eisenhower Park
6.3 km / 3.9 mi
Hotel facilities & services
Services and fees can vary. Check the selected room details and hotel policies before booking.
- Year of construction: 1983
- Year of most recent renovation: 2014
- Total number of rooms: 269
- Number of floors (main building): 9
- Single rooms: 192
- Double rooms: 80
- Junior suites: 1
- Suites: 16
- Accessible rooms: 8
- hotel
- American Express
- JCB
Show 76 more facilities & services
- Diners Club
- MasterCard
- Visa
- City centre
- Bus/Train station
- Nearest Bus / Metro Stop
- Airport
- Beach
- Golf course
- Entertainment Area
- Wheelchair-accessible
- Car park
- 24-hour reception
- Check-in hour
- Check-out hour
- Mobile phone coverage
- Wi-fi
- Valet parkingExtra charge
- Room service
- Laundry service
- Bicycle hire service
- Babysitting serviceExtra charge
- Multilingual staff
- 24-hour securityExtra charge
- Bellboy service
- Air conditioning in public areas
- Fireplace
- Hotel safe
- Currency exchange facilities
- Cloakroom
- Lift access
- Newspaper stand
- Shop
- Garden
- Terrace
- Bicycle storage
- Concierge
- Sun terrace
- Gym
- Newspapers
- Luggage room
- Clothes dryer
- Café
- Bar
- Restaurant: 3
- Non-smoking area
- Smoking area
- Highchairs
- Poolside snack bar
- Banquet hall
- Air conditioning in Restaurant
- Conference room
- Meeting room
- Business centre
- Indoor freshwater pool: 1
- Sun loungers
- Parasols
- TV lounge
- Pub
- Sauna
- Steam bath
- Massage
- Spa treatments
- Hairdressing salon
- Spa centreExtra charge
- Breakfast
- Continental breakfast
- À la carte lunch
- Set menu lunch
- À la carte dinner
- Set menu dinner
- Special dietary options
- Non-smoking establishment
- Fitness
- Cycling / mountain biking
- Golf practice facilityExtra charge
Meal plans
Meal plan types
Meal options depend on the room and rate you choose. Search your dates to see which meal plans are included.
Upon availability
Room types
These are the hotel's room types, rather than live offers. Choose your travel dates to see available rooms, prices and booking conditions. Check availability
-
DOUBLE DELUXEDOUBLE • DELUXEDBL.DX
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE DELUXE
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBL.DX
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
DOUBLE DELUXE KING BEDDOUBLE • DELUXE KING BED • 1 Bedroom • 5 m²DBL.DX-KG
Room overview
Non-smoking room- Room size
- 5 m²
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 2 • Children: max. 1
- Bed setup
- King-size bed 150-183 width
- Bedrooms
- 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE KING BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room amenities
- Radio
- TV
- Direct dial telephone
- Hairdryer
- Bathtub
- Shower
- Bathroom
- Minibar
Show all 15 amenities
- Tea and coffee making facilities
- Ironing set
- Carpeted floors
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
- Individually adjustable heating
- Safe
- Terrace
Facilities with extra charge
- Wi-fi
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE DELUXE KING BED
Room photos
6 photosSelect a photo to open the full-screen viewer.
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailable Photos illustrate the room type; your assigned room may vary.
Room overview
Non-smoking room- Room size
- 5 m²
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 2 • Children: max. 1
- Bed setup
- King-size bed 150-183 width
- Bedrooms
- 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE KING BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBL.DX-KG
Room amenities
- Radio
- TV
- Direct dial telephone
- Hairdryer
- Bathtub
- Shower
- Bathroom
- Minibar
- Tea and coffee making facilities
- Ironing set
- Carpeted floors
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
- Individually adjustable heating
- Safe
- Terrace
Facilities with extra charge
- Wi-fi
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Room DELUXERoom • DELUXEROO.DX
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Room DELUXE
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: ROO.DX
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
DOUBLE STANDARDDOUBLE • STANDARDDBL.ST
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE STANDARD
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBL.ST
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Room DELUXE TWO BEDSRoom • DELUXE TWO BEDSROO.2B-DX
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Room DELUXE TWO BEDS
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: ROO.2B-DX
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
DOUBLE KING SIZE BEDDOUBLE • KING SIZE BEDDBL.KG
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- KING SIZE BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE KING SIZE BED
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- KING SIZE BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBL.KG
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Double or Twin CAPACITY 2Double or Twin • CAPACITY 2DBT.C2
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- CAPACITY 2
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Double or Twin CAPACITY 2
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- CAPACITY 2
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBT.C2
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Room RUN OF HOUSERoom • RUN OF HOUSEROO.RO
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- RUN OF HOUSE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Room RUN OF HOUSE
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–10 • Adults: max. 10 • Children: max. 6
- Room type
- Room
- View / characteristic
- RUN OF HOUSE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: ROO.RO
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
DOUBLE DELUXE TWO DOUBLE BEDSDOUBLE • DELUXE TWO DOUBLE BEDS • 1 Bedroom • 5 m²DBL.2D-DX
Room overview
Non-smoking room- Room size
- 5 m²
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 2 • Children: max. 1
- Bed setup
- Double bed 131-150 width
- Bedrooms
- 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO DOUBLE BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room amenities
- Safe
- Individually adjustable heating
- Bathroom
- Terrace
- Shower
- Bathtub
- Hairdryer
- Direct dial telephone
Show all 15 amenities
- TV
- Radio
- Minibar
- Tea and coffee making facilities
- Ironing set
- Carpeted floors
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
Facilities with extra charge
- Wi-fi
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE DELUXE TWO DOUBLE BEDS
Room photos
3 photosSelect a photo to open the full-screen viewer.
Photos illustrate the room type; your assigned room may vary.
Room overview
Non-smoking room- Room size
- 5 m²
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 2 • Children: max. 1
- Bed setup
- Double bed 131-150 width
- Bedrooms
- 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO DOUBLE BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBL.2D-DX
Room amenities
- Safe
- Individually adjustable heating
- Bathroom
- Terrace
- Shower
- Bathtub
- Hairdryer
- Direct dial telephone
- TV
- Radio
- Minibar
- Tea and coffee making facilities
- Ironing set
- Carpeted floors
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
Facilities with extra charge
- Wi-fi
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Double or Twin STANDARDDouble or Twin • STANDARDDBT.ST
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Double or Twin STANDARD
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBT.ST
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
DOUBLE SINGLE USE STANDARDDOUBLE SINGLE USE • STANDARDDUS.ST
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 1 • Children: max. 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE SINGLE USE
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
DOUBLE SINGLE USE STANDARD
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–2 • Adults: max. 1 • Children: max. 1
- Room type
- DOUBLE SINGLE USE
- View / characteristic
- STANDARD
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DUS.ST
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
TWIN DELUXETWIN • DELUXETWN.DX
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- TWIN
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
TWIN DELUXE
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–4 • Adults: max. 4 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- TWIN
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: TWN.DX
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Double or Twin WITH DOUBLE BEDDouble or Twin • WITH DOUBLE BEDDBT.DB
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- WITH DOUBLE BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Double or Twin WITH DOUBLE BED
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- WITH DOUBLE BED
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBT.DB
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
-
Double or Twin DELUXE TWO BEDSDouble or Twin • DELUXE TWO BEDSDBT.2B-DX
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
Check availabilityThe Garden City Hotel
Double or Twin DELUXE TWO BEDS
Room photos
Photos are not available for this room type.
Room overview
- Occupancy
- Guests: 1–6 • Adults: max. 6 • Children: max. 3
- Room type
- Double or Twin
- View / characteristic
- DELUXE TWO BEDS
Adult and child limits apply within the room's total guest limit.
Room code: DBT.2B-DX
Limited room details from hotel
Available rooms, prices and included facilities are confirmed after you choose your dates and rate.
No room types match your search. Try a room name or feature such as a balcony.
Guest reviews
What other guests saying about The Garden City Hotel
100
reviews shown
Jennifer
Large, clean, quite room, exceptionally responsive staff, safe and attractive location close to restaurants and cafes. We would definitely return here.
Kerry
Clean friendly staff enjoyed the stay
Walter
Amazing luxury experience at this classy hotel. Staff is amazing, restaurants are fantastic and more dining and shopping is just a block away. Classic Long Island Main Street setting is also wonderful, and across the street you can grab the train to manhattan for more of the New York experience. Highly recommend!
sander
Ok
Alexander
After a previous experience that missed the mark, I have to give credit to The Garden City Hotel team for listening and making things right.
Our return stay was exactly what we hoped for—smooth check-in, great service, a wonderful lunch on property, and we fully enjoyed the amenities including the gym and pool.
A special thank you to Angelina and the team for showing true hospitality and making sure we had a great experience. Having grown up in the area, this hotel has always been a Long Island landmark, and we’re happy to say we’ll definitely be returning for future stays.
Our return stay was exactly what we hoped for—smooth check-in, great service, a wonderful lunch on property, and we fully enjoyed the amenities including the gym and pool.
A special thank you to Angelina and the team for showing true hospitality and making sure we had a great experience. Having grown up in the area, this hotel has always been a Long Island landmark, and we’re happy to say we’ll definitely be returning for future stays.
Susan
Friendliness, helpfulness, professionalism of all staff was outstanding. Highly recommended.
Nadine
Everything was perfect. We had breakfast in bed after a long day before for our wedding. It was the perfect ending to our day. Wish we stayed longer.
Joseph
Be careful when ordering room service. We ordered a sandwich and flatbread. We thought it was from the restaurant, but it was from the gift shop reheated flatbread, and a pre-made sandwich.
Thomas
The staff was incredible, considerate, sweet, helpful, fantastic. I hope they are paid well. Because this place charges an outrageous amount of money for a hotel that is neither historical/interesting nor modern/luxurious. What was supposedly a beautiful, historic hotel was torn down in the '70s. This place was built in the 80's. Unfortunately, it shows. The bathrooms in the rooms have been updated, and the rooms are spacious, but expect a noisy air conditioner, a view of a parking lot and a $50 per-head breakfast buffet swarming with fruit flies.
Seems like a lovely place to get married or attend a high school prom. But this place needs to rebrand/remodel/redecorate or rethink its pricing. One could argue it's a great location. But I've paid the same amount per-night to stay in a fairytale, picturesque \"grandhotel\" built in the 1600's on the shore of an alpine lake in Switzerland. Seems like the Garden City Hotel could use some more local competition.
Seems like a lovely place to get married or attend a high school prom. But this place needs to rebrand/remodel/redecorate or rethink its pricing. One could argue it's a great location. But I've paid the same amount per-night to stay in a fairytale, picturesque \"grandhotel\" built in the 1600's on the shore of an alpine lake in Switzerland. Seems like the Garden City Hotel could use some more local competition.
Alex
Awesome Stay, great accommodations
Lucia
We always enjoy staying at the Garden City Hotel and have been returning twice a year—every summer and winter—for many years. The hotel itself is beautiful, but what truly makes our stay special is the incredible staff. Everyone is warm, professional, and welcoming. The housekeeping team does a wonderful job, and the valet staff are always friendly, helpful, and attentive. They consistently make us feel at home, and we truly appreciate their hard work.
The only disappointment during this stay was our family dinner at King’s Restaurant. Unfortunately, the quality of the food did not meet the high standards we have come to expect from the hotel. The dishes lacked the level of preparation and excellence that such a wonderful property deserves. We hope management will address this, as improving the restaurant experience would make the hotel truly exceptional.
Overall, we love staying here and look forward to returning again soon.
The only disappointment during this stay was our family dinner at King’s Restaurant. Unfortunately, the quality of the food did not meet the high standards we have come to expect from the hotel. The dishes lacked the level of preparation and excellence that such a wonderful property deserves. We hope management will address this, as improving the restaurant experience would make the hotel truly exceptional.
Overall, we love staying here and look forward to returning again soon.
Dana
It was a perfect stay. It’s a well maintained hotel and the service is top notch. The food was excellent.
Ali
Nice
Rachel
Amazing staff and stay. Highly recommend.
ADRIAN
Excelent.
Danielle
Great experience
James
It was ok. Not much else to write about
Cindy
Personal
Michael
Great hidden gem in a great town.
Samantha
The hotel is beautiful and the staff were excellent. We checked in around 8pm to just stay the night, we weren’t related to any of the big events going on at the hotel.
Unfortunately, we were placed in a room on the second floor, very close to the large event. We could hear the music thumping all night. Thankfully it ended by 11, but would have much appreciated to be placed further away from the festivities. I didn’t bother saying anything because we were so tired and I am pregnant.
The mattresses are very firm, if you like that.
The room service was far superior to any room service I’ve ever had in my life - it was a delicious omelette and sandwich spread. Came right on time, still wonderfully warm.
Unfortunately, we were placed in a room on the second floor, very close to the large event. We could hear the music thumping all night. Thankfully it ended by 11, but would have much appreciated to be placed further away from the festivities. I didn’t bother saying anything because we were so tired and I am pregnant.
The mattresses are very firm, if you like that.
The room service was far superior to any room service I’ve ever had in my life - it was a delicious omelette and sandwich spread. Came right on time, still wonderfully warm.
Barbara
Loved the speakeasy and the the staff is friendly and helpful. Our favorite place to stay
loundy
I had a great stay. The restaurant was great too. The room was clean but by the window behind the curtain was not so clean. We enjoyed the chocolate covered strawberries. Breakfast ended too early. It rained so we had to stay in the hotel most of the time. The gym was great. The pool was warm and cozy but the kids were splashing water and stayed near the flatter surface area of the pool so I had to stay in the shallow while being short. I didn’t enjoy that.
Philip
No
Theresa
Bathrooms are lovely but could use more counter space. Wonderful historic hotel!
Rose
Not impressed at all for the price
Ditte
Great hotel! Our room was very nice and spacious. We had a wonderful stay!
Lucy
Always a pleasure to stay. Staff are wonderful
Peter
It’s a big full service hotel and I thought good value. Large corner room with 2 windows and views. Large bathroom decorated brilliant white. Leather sofa in room. Coffee and pastries available early downstairs Saturday morning as alternative to room service or restaurant. Staff all helpful.
Dolapo
Did not have breakfast.
Natasha
Room was nice. But was on the same floor as banquet rooms. So music and hallway was very loud at night. By the end of the party it was better
Vinil
NA
Stacey
It was ok
Harry
Clean room
Alexander
After 150 years in operation, you’d expect this hotel to have mastered hospitality. It hasn’t.
As an Expedia Platinum member with 40+ stays this year across top hotels in NY, LA, Miami, and Europe, I understand the difference between policy and service. This property fails on the latter.
My fiancée arrived ahead of me for check-in. The hotel called me to verify her identity, which I confirmed immediately. Despite that, they still refused to check her in, leaving her waiting in the lobby for nearly two hours. No urgency, no courtesy, no effort to recover, despite a time-sensitive schedule for a VIP event at UBS Arena.
The next morning didn’t improve. I requested a late checkout to have breakfast on property. After a 20-minute discussion with a manager, they granted a minimal extension but failed to mention breakfast ends at 10am. We arrived expecting service, only to be turned away and left waiting for lunch.
That’s not a minor oversight, it’s a lack of operational awareness.
For a hotel that leans on a 150-year legacy, the service feels rigid and disconnected. At every stage, there was an opportunity to elevate the experience—and it was missed.
As an Expedia Platinum member with 40+ stays this year across top hotels in NY, LA, Miami, and Europe, I understand the difference between policy and service. This property fails on the latter.
My fiancée arrived ahead of me for check-in. The hotel called me to verify her identity, which I confirmed immediately. Despite that, they still refused to check her in, leaving her waiting in the lobby for nearly two hours. No urgency, no courtesy, no effort to recover, despite a time-sensitive schedule for a VIP event at UBS Arena.
The next morning didn’t improve. I requested a late checkout to have breakfast on property. After a 20-minute discussion with a manager, they granted a minimal extension but failed to mention breakfast ends at 10am. We arrived expecting service, only to be turned away and left waiting for lunch.
That’s not a minor oversight, it’s a lack of operational awareness.
For a hotel that leans on a 150-year legacy, the service feels rigid and disconnected. At every stage, there was an opportunity to elevate the experience—and it was missed.
Dimitrios
Breakfast was fresh at the staff were very attentive.
Sergio
Clean rooms
Jeffrey
Superb is the only word I have to describe my experience!
Mary
Excellent all around
Amanda
We were in town to tour colleges and this hotel is by far the nicest in the area. Highly recommend.
Shavon
This was my husband and I's second time staying here. The staff is always friendly and helpful. I had a last-minute request to add strawberries and macarons with a Happy Anniversary note to our room pre-arrival, and they accommodated me. The drinks at King Bar are delicious, my husband really enjoyed the crab cakes as well. The breakfast buffet was ok. The rooms are always very clean. The pool was also great. We didn't get to go to the speakeasy, but hope to go the next time we are there.
Eddie
Met expectations
Keith
Room and property was clean. Great bar, bartenders were friendly.
Tania
Very clean, spacious room. If you’re taller than 5”7’ your feet might dangle off the bed
Monina
Beautiful
Thomas
Beautiful hotel
Great staff
Great staff
Sergio
Great stay, and beautiful property.
Dhananjay
Clean room, polite hospitable staff
John
Short walk to Village for many food options.
hyman
0759
Tanis
We were charged $40 a night facility fee!! Not impressed! Not even a free coffee in the morning!
Pamela
Having to go down the hallway to use the microwave in a staff elevator/laundry chute area was not great.
Staff very courteous and helpful. Texted the staff a question and the response was immediate and thorough.
Staff very courteous and helpful. Texted the staff a question and the response was immediate and thorough.
Ted
Would rate the property 3+/4-. Carpet and curtain stains, peeling paint were eyesores. Room blinds would not release to cover the window and the window curtains had to be propped with a cushion to approximate closure. Limited in-room coffee. Friendly, attentive staff. Mixed reviews for King Bar and the Marketplace.
Eric
We were there for a 1 night stay. Through our Hotels.Com booking, we received a $20 coupon to use in the hotel. Ok, we figured let have a couple of glasses of wine @the Bar before leaving for dinner. We requested Bar level wines (not too shelf) which were presented nicely. To our dismay, the cost of each glass of wine was $20. So, the bill was $40 + a $5 tip. We found that to be exorbitant. On checkout, we complained about the pricing but the front desk would/could not do anything to reduce that, claiming no Manager was available to assist. We were then directed to the Food Manager who also would/could not assisted but took our info and explained they would be alerted to our complaint. Waiting for a call.
Thomas
Great
MEGHAN
The food was very expensive but that was about the only negative.
Juan
Nothing bad to say, we only spent a limit time of the one night there, loved the room, and staff was very friendly and helpful.
Cecilia
Tucked inside a Quiet Upscale community, no street parking surrounding the area, 1 entrance, the GC Hotel offers Complete Privacy. An Iconic Hotel with Modern features, mixed with the elegance of antique Wood & Brass. The Staff is Professional, Very Nice & accommodating. The spa is elegant, work out area small yet spotless as is the indoor pool. Thursday night the Bar was quite Lively! KUDOS to the Door & Valet Attendants & GiGi in the Coffee Shop!
Derek
One of the best places to stay when on the Island.
Paul
Unable to regulate the temperature in our room. The thermostat registered 61 and the temperature was well above 75.
Carla
Always consistent with clean rooms and staff are very friendly. Great place to stay!!
tania
Restaurant staff
Clean room
Clean room
Dana
Beautiful room, excellent and courteous staff, great location and amenities. I would absolutely stay here again!
Tanika
Great service and it was a convenience for my hospital visit to NYU. Hubby said, \" the bar made 2 of the best cocktails he ever had in his life\". He's a wine Sommelier so this is a huge compliment.
Carla
Room was spotless and staff were excellent. Love staying here!!!
Monina
Great!!
Rosana
Horrific . So bad I had to leave
Kim
Clean room and great staff.
CLIFTON
Room was very clean, bed was very comfy.
Anastasia
The staff was wonderful. I love staying here!
JeanMarie
Beautiful
William
Clean room nice staff
Sean
Great staff
GERALDINE
The room was spacious and clean. Very comfortable.
Laura
Staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Room was clean. Breakfast choice was perfect. A very enjoyable stay.
Laina
Room was clean and quiet
lynda
beautiful classy hotel
Isabella
Perfect place for a local getaway!!! Good food, Clean rooms, and relaxing resort like spa!!
Michael
Pleasant staff, clean, few areas needed an upgrade. Pool area was freezing, pool was warm. Inquired, engineering sent, couldnt fix problem.
Esame
Satisfied
Marie
Beautiful hotel but only one elevator working on New Years Eve with ballrooms plus hotel at full capacity. Sometimes waiting a half an hour for the elevator. No comps or apologies
Louis
From the valet to check in everybody was professional the rooms were clean. They definitely need a little updating, but we stayed there a few times and it’s just a nice place to stay.
Malika
Breakfast is delightful but I would love to have a hot water tea bar in the room.
Elena
Service was great. Hotel was immaculate. Was not 5 star because the room could have had actual coffee k-cups and enough water for the party. Great stay — will be back soon!
Donna
Staff and valet parking attendants were amazing!
Tomika
Room was comfortable and clean. The restaurants are nice. Staff very accommodating. When I expressed that I was hungry after hours, they opened the cafe for me. I would definitely stay again.
Michelle
Staff was great! For an upscale hotel it’s ridiculous that you have to buy coffee for almost $5 a cup when most “average“ hotels have complimentary. The TV signal was very weak. Granted, we were not there to watch television, but would’ve appreciated it for our downtime.
sharon
Breakfast is grab & go situation.. there is no breakfast per se, but decent options. Yogurt, fruit muffins coffee. Hotel is classical and beautiful, staff members are top shelf and the room is spacious, clean quiet and comfortable. Location makes it special & walkable.
Celeste
The room is spacious, clean, and the bed is very comfortable.
pitram
My stay was wonderful. Clean room and helpful staff.
Lance
Magnificent experience
tamara
yes all was good
Suzanne
Staff was outstanding
Frank
Clean an safe beautiful area
john
yes it was fresh but not free
Shelby
Nice hotel. Busy with weddings! Room was good size. A little musty smelling and the furnishings and carpet a little dated. Bathroom nice. Someplace to put a make up bag would be good. Not much counter space. Overall would stay again.
Maria
Location, service, amenities
Patricia
It was a pleasure staying again at the Garden city hotel. Luis in front is always friendly and accommodating.
Carlos
excellent. Everyone was very helpful
Frank
Clean room, Staff was extremely courteous
Jonathan
Friendly staff, comfortable clean room, and great food.
Location & surroundings
The Garden City Hotel
45 7Th St, Garden City, United States
Hotels Nearby
Compare other stays close to this hotel. Choose travel dates to check availability.
Show 46 more nearby hotels
The Garden City Hotel
80 hotel photos
